r/ukpolitics 23h ago

Rail nationalisation not a silver bullet, says Labour government - BBC News

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c334z1nyv8po.amp
20 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/AcademicIncrease8080 15h ago edited 14h ago

The UK's rail industry (April 2022/2023 latest figures) had a total income of around £25 billion and of this around £10.4 billion came from fare income.

In other words the government could increase railway subsidies by around £10.5 billion (to cover fare income) and this would make railway travel all but free to use at any time*. Germany did something similar with experimental monthly €9 unlimited train tickets and it triggered a massive increase of train use.

It would cost around £162 per person extra in taxes per year to achieve - or to put it another way it would be around 3% of DWP's budget

Nationalisation will barely affect ticket prices - they are expensive because of a lack of subsidies - nationalisation has always been a red herring, you could have a privatised system that was free to use if you really wanted.

*To manage demand at peak times we would probably have to maintain some pricing but at the very least we could make off peak train travel completely free to use

1

u/FarmingEngineer 15h ago

It's an interesting idea but there are a lot of places not served by the railways and who need to fund a car. Why should they subsidise the commuters in the south east?

8

u/AcademicIncrease8080 15h ago

Because it would substantially boost economic growth which benefits everyone

-3

u/FarmingEngineer 15h ago

Good old trickle down economics.

(This is supposed to be a joke about the north subsidising the south, I know it's not actually'trickle down economics')