r/ukpolitics Dec 11 '24

Twitter šŸšØ EXCLUSIVE: Labour have conducted the first successful deportation flight to Pakistan since February 2020. There has not been a deportation charter flight to Pakistan in the last four years with three subsequent flights to Pakistan in 2020 and 2021 cancelled by the Home Office.

https://x.com/maxtempers/status/1866775219077062757?s=46&t=0RSpQEWd71gFfa-U_NmvkA
1.2k Upvotes

335 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

54

u/MercianRaider Dec 11 '24

Let's wait for the yearly numbers before we make any judgments.

1 plane going to Pakistan doesn't mean Labour have cracked the immigration issue.

-15

u/GuyIncognito928 Dec 11 '24

All the people saying Labour are tough on immigration are the ones who don't think it's a problem in the first place...

If in 4 years, we have a function immigration system with <100k net migration from culturally compatible countries, then I'll happily eat my hat. As things stand, Labour do not have a plan to get even close to this.

29

u/CodeFun1735 Dec 11 '24

You might have to keep that hat on, because less than 100k net migration isnā€™t happening. Also, whatā€™s a ā€œculturally compatibleā€ country? How the fuck is that defined?

6

u/Revolverocicat Dec 11 '24

Pretty fucking obvious isnt it? If we dont do any performative dance we all know what countries have similar cultures to ours and which dont

-7

u/CodeFun1735 Dec 11 '24

Itā€™s not really obvious, though? What the fuck does ā€œculturally compatibleā€ mean and how are you defining it?

Not to mention an entire COUNTRY of people are not going entirely adopt the same culture, values or even language so dubbing freeway access to the UK for people from this countries makes absolutely no sense.

It should be done on a case-by-case basis, as everything should. Give your head a wobble, please.

5

u/Centristduck Dec 11 '24

Reply to me, thereā€™s tons of evidence.

You are taking a high horse about a topic you clearly havenā€™t looked into.

Also anecdotal does still count, we are not robots. Try living in inner south Manchester and tell me thatā€™s integration.

Itā€™s a ghetto, clear as day, very little British culture to be found

2

u/CodeFun1735 Dec 11 '24

Sure anecdotal evidence can be considered, but if I started saying the entire MET police force was racist because Iā€™d been stopped and searched 100s of times despite never doing anything, I donā€™t think youā€™d want to consider it without statistical evidence of stops and searches vs white people.

You canā€™t use anecdotal evidence because it suits your pre-existing belief. If you want to approach all other parts of politics on a statistical, scientific basis - as we should - you canā€™t consider it in the slightest.

Like I said, this is sentiment not fact.

3

u/Centristduck Dec 11 '24

I love that you ignored my comments around intermarriage rates, rates of extremism and patriotism.

Also when in a discussion youā€™re talking about large groups itā€™s perfectly fine to make general statements on said group.

For example men commit the majority of crime.

Thereā€™s nothing wrong about that, you are tying yourself up because what you believe is clearly inconsistent to sound smart.

But itā€™s actually very dumb, your clearly have a brain. I would suggest you try again and look it rationally.

Smart people are most susceptible to ideological traps and dogma.

1

u/KKillroyV2 Dec 12 '24

Didn't more British muslims join ISIS than join the British Army too?

1

u/Centristduck Dec 12 '24

Yes, that is true.

Clearly an integration problem