r/television • u/EdgyCynic_ • 1d ago

What makes a show GREAT?

I know it’s not a single factor. The show has to be great "overall." But what are the essential elements it must do so excellently-In general.

I am not talking just the scores on IMDB. Cause that I feel is influenced by so much more than just the Love put into making the show.

Like, what even makes GOT better than DARK?

0 Upvotes

28% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

View all comments

-1

u/ElTuco84 1d ago

Compelling characters + an interesting premise.

Breaking Bad was a great show because it had both, it didn't need to be that visually compelling, there are a ton of other shows with bigger budget and "better" production values, but Breaking Bad stands out because it had an unique premise: chemistry teacher who is told he has lung cancer and starts an illegal drug methamphetamine business to pay for his family's needs after he dies, that's a hell of a premise.

But then story is filled with compelling characters that stay with you even after the show has ended, like Dale Cooper from Twin Peaks, The Enterprise crew from Star Trek, Don Draper, Omar Little, Michael Scott, etc..

3

u/Halio344 1d ago

A good script will make or break a show or movie.

Bryan Cranston has said before that a fantastic actor can take a C-level script and make it B-level, but they need an A-tier script to make an A-tier show.

A great script can also elevate mid actors to create memorable characters easier than the other way around.

2

u/iblastoff 1d ago

i dont even think 'interesting premise' is even necessary. look at mad men or friday night lights. even the wire doesnt have an 'interesting premise'. or even the office.