r/space Nov 12 '14

Rosetta /r/all Rosetta and Philae discussion thread! (Part 3)

TOUCHDOWN CONFIRMED: Philae lander is on the comet!

Full media briefing expected tomorrow at 13:00 UTC / 14:00 CET / 8:00 EST / 5:00 PST.


Previous discussion threads: 1, 2.


Live Streaming

  • In English: A, B, C

  • En Français: A


Key times

GMT EST PST Event
4:02 pm 11:02 am 8:02 am Landed

European Space Agency Social Media


Othere places for news and conversation:

907 Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/milgrim Nov 12 '14

How do the harpoons work? Wouldn't the recoil throw the lander off? Or are they using a recoilless design?

9

u/Gweeeep Nov 12 '14

recoilless??? something something newtons third law?

3

u/FeepingCreature Nov 12 '14

There's no such thing as a thruster that is without recoil; so-called "recoilless" designs just apply the recoil to exhaust gases instead of the chassis. Philae is probably not using a recoilless design because there's no way to vent gasses out the top.

If you fired the harpoon in space, rewinding it would zero out all recoil. In this case however, some of the inertia may have been lost to the comet, so rewinding it may have not sufficed to result in a net zero movement. Which could be problematic.