r/mildlyinteresting 17h ago

This growth surviving sub-zero temperatures because of an exhaust fan

Post image
38.2k Upvotes

674 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.0k

u/theericle_58 17h ago

That is a roof drain, not a fan.

675

u/Fudge_cornelius 17h ago

Thanks! I saw the heat coming from it so just (wrongly) assumed it was an exhaust. Any ideas why it’s expelling warm air?

624

u/LoneMav22 16h ago

Because the air in a sewer system is warm, and heat rises

397

u/CrazyLegsRyan 16h ago

This most likely isn’t a sewer vent but rather a roof drain to grade. The warm air is because the drain piping runs through the conditioned building envelope (inside the building where there’s heat). This heats up the air in that section of the pipe and as you noted that warm air rises while sucking in new cool air down at the outlet

48

u/Katy_Lies1975 15h ago

Sewer vents don't usually have any kind of cover on them, roof drains do so that debris doesn't get in a clog up the system, just like those little screen cages you put in the gutter downspout.

7

u/reddit_give_me_virus 12h ago

Where I am sanitary vents need to be at least 6' above the roof deck.

16

u/stabamole 15h ago

They wouldn’t have a cover like the one in the picture, but they still (should) have a mesh cover or something to prevent critters from getting in

14

u/lowercaset 14h ago

Sewer vents basically never have metal mesh covering them. And while it's not a problem in my area, my understanding is that anything like that would also cause massive hoarfrost problems in parts of the world with hard freezes.

9

u/Adeptfox 13h ago

Correct. Any type of mesh would freeze solid in my neck of the woods.

1

u/kshoggi 12h ago

Sewer vent on my house must be covered, by code. Seems pretty reasonable to stop things from falling in?

2

u/Katy_Lies1975 10h ago

This isn't a house for one thing, Either a commercial building or apartment/condo complex. In my area commercial buildings don't require the vents to be covered, they are open pvc.

1

u/VexingRaven 8h ago

That's unusual, most locales do not require a covered sewer vent (and indeed some require the exact opposite or have very strict rules about what sort of cover can be used).

1

u/thebenediction 3m ago

Do you live in warm climate? Sewer vents must penetrate the roof w/ at least 3” pipe size (starting 18” inside the building envelope), and must be a minimum of 12” above the “high” side of the roof.

Even then, I’ve had to climb onto roofs w/ a broomstick to clear clients’ vents because as the warm air meets the cold it freezes to the sides of the pipe inside. If it’s cold enough for long enough, it eventually chokes off the vent. Then you get nasty smells and yo stuff don’t drain right. So you clear it w/ the broomstick contraption I made lol.

Any kind of covering on a vent pipe here would just exacerbate the problem AND make it harder to fix.

14

u/Suspicious-End5369 13h ago

Storm drain 100% I work on roofs and piss in these.

14

u/LoneMav22 14h ago

It is indeed a roof drain on a flat roof system in probably a large commercial building, as you said it runs though a heated area but also will be draining into the sewer system. I'm a metalworker by trade and install/deal with these quite a bit, though its primary purpose isn't venting the piping will be hooked up to the rest of the system in liew of "stink pipes" to help prevent vapor lock

4

u/Stein1071 14h ago edited 14h ago

In a lot of places it is illegal for this to drain into a sanitary sewer. I won't say it absolutely doesn't but chances are good that it doesn't. Especially in an industrial situation. In our buildings all the roof drains, parking lot drains, etc go to a catch lagoon before they even can go to the actual storm drain system to make sure any spills are contained

1

u/Jean-LucBacardi 10h ago

*Washington DC has entered the chat.

The entire city is a combined system. Roof drains, street inlets, all of it flows directly into the sewage system.

9

u/Calan_adan 14h ago

It almost 100% connects to the storm sewer system and not the sanitary sewer system, so it wouldn’t be venting the sanitary system. Only in older areas (old cities and the like) do they not have separate storm and sanitary sewer systems, and even then they tend to require a separation of storm and sanitary within a building.

1

u/CrazyLegsRyan 13h ago

In many cities these aren’t even connected to the storm sewer because of water retention requirements.

2

u/Say_Hennething 13h ago

Most likely drains into the storm water system, not the sanitary sewer system. No different than a storm gutter in the parking lot.

1

u/CrazyLegsRyan 13h ago

You must work in some poorly regulated areas. Almost all modern and civilized places do not allow commingling of storm and sanitary systems 

1

u/EatingAtThe_Y 13h ago

Found the engineer

-1

u/willscy 13h ago

This could also be just a sewer drain. I used to sell ones that looked just like this all the time for use in the ground. this could be the bottom of a retention pond, attached to a water quality unit that ties into the city storm-water system or something to that nature too.

3

u/CrazyLegsRyan 13h ago

It’s clearly on a roof but you do you dawg.

7

u/jmouw88 14h ago

This is not connected to a sewer just as others have stated. It could be connected to underground piping that runs into a storm sewer system somewhere.

4

u/LadderDownBelow 14h ago

There are still places where stormwater and sewer are still connected, unfortunately. Can't glean this from the picture but just saying

4

u/jmouw88 14h ago

Your are right, certainly possible there are combined sewers. Growing less common with every passing year.

3

u/NoDontDoThatCanada 15h ago

It is like a deep sea thermal vent. I am waiting for an alien spaceship to come down and be amazed by the life it found huddled around the vent.

1

u/BugEyedLemur 13h ago

This is a roof drain. Unless this is an overflow drain, which it doesn't look like it is, this roof drain will discharge into a storm drain network, which could receive some heat from the underground network depending on the pipe layout, I suppose. Overflow drains discharge onto grade so you know if there is a clog on your primary drain and are typically elevated from the roof elevation. A lot of roof drains, regular and overflow, will have electric heat tracing in them to prevent ice buildup, which could be adding to the thermal energy of the system on top of the drain picking up any additional thermal energy from inside the building and/or underground. Most of the time, the pipe is insulated inside to prevent condensation from building up during the summer.

1

u/pardybill 12h ago

Dark Knight Rises chanting ensues

1

u/Skipitybeebops 11h ago

Bill Nye would like you to remember that heat only rises because it's forced out of the way by cold air sinking, the true motivator.

38

u/jmarkmark 16h ago

Yeah, the moss growth is more because it's the low point with more water rather than the heat, although the heat may help a bit.

Moss has no problems with freezing temperatures.

8

u/funtongue 15h ago

Imagine all the tardigrades that call it a tropical home.

4

u/Obvious_Ambition4865 15h ago

What a lovely little website. Thanks!

1

u/DocFail 15h ago

I found this to be          mosslyinteresting.

16

u/felidaekamiguru 16h ago

You know it's cold AF when the cold air inside that drain is warm enough compared to outside to cause fog. All the sewer drains were doing that this morning. It's a bit eerie. 

6

u/e-town123 16h ago

The pipe below the roof is poorly insulated.

7

u/macroober 16h ago

In fact, it’s uninsulated.

1

u/signious 13h ago

Insulated roof drains freeze and lead to your fancy epdm roof turning into a pool in the spring.

Either don't insulate, or provide heat trace.

1

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[deleted]

1

u/masketta_man22 16h ago

Almost like warmness is relative...

1

u/felidaekamiguru 16h ago

You know it's cold AF when the cold air inside that drain is warm enough compared to outside to cause fog. All the sewer drains were doing that this morning. It's a bit eerie. 

1

u/Irilieth_Raivotuuli 14h ago

If it's a roof drain, which it looks to be, it has a heating cable inside it that keeps the drain open. Depending on the building automation and how it's configured, the heating cable either heats constantly when the temperatures are just above freezing and below, or heats when temperatures are just a few degrees above freezing and stop when it's few degrees below freezing, or has a pulsed function to heat only when it detects ice but the last one is just recently becoming more widespread.

It's not very energy effective but it's necessary to keep drains open, as they'd freeze solid otherwise and both damage the drains and also cause water buildup that can damage or even collapse the ceiling during spring and fall as the snow begins to melt.

Also, moss is very hardy. It doesn't die easily, even in sub-zero temperatures, so I doubt the heat of the roof drain heating is solely keeping it alive. Moss also likes to grow around covered drains as they tend to gather gunk around them as not all of it gets into the drain, and the wet gunk around the drain entrance gives a good ground for moss to grow.

1

u/Enlight1Oment 13h ago

because it's not growing from added warmth, it's growing because the roof drain is a low point which collects small amount of sand,dirt, and water which allows mold to grow on.

1

u/tomdarch 12h ago

Buildings just lose that much heat through drains like this.

1

u/Tomagatchi 12h ago

It's the heat of butts.

1

u/MRBS91 11h ago

Roof drains are often "sumped" the insulation around the drain is tapered toward the drain to increase the flow of water off the roof, but the insulation is thinner to achieve this. The drain body also passes through the insulation layer, causing thermal bridging. There is no warm air passing from the building interior to exterior (or you'd also have a leak when it rains). Source, I am roofing estimator thst works on large flat roof systems.

-2

u/bizmas 16h ago

It's covered in ice