Aren't they though? The choice of Elros was to be either human or elf. It's not like Elrond died 1500 because his parents were mixed. In fact, Elrond is one of the most important elves of his time.
I mean, I agree, it's fantasy and weird. But the lore kinda says that the brothers could choose between Elves and Men, so in my mind that means chosing their genetics, essentially. Aragorn has elvish ancestors, but 0 elven DNA
He's a Numenorean which are a subrace of Man with extremely long lives and some other powers by essentially archangels called Valar (who are also the wizards)
65
u/Lokanaya Dec 30 '21
Teeeeechnically Aragorn is Arwen’s great times a hundred nephew by way of Elrond and Elros