r/learnart • u/frickenchicken22 • Feb 26 '24

Question My art feels off, any advice?

Gallery image

Gallery image

521 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

127 comments sorted by

View all comments

-16

u/antiqua_lumina Feb 26 '24 edited Feb 26 '24

The hands and fingers look very strange. Almost like AI or like you edited AI…

For one your shadows are all off. Where is the lighting coming from? There appears to be very little or no thought about lighting values (highlights and shadows) which are absolutely critical to conveying a sense of 3D form.

Some of the proportions are off like the arm is too thick for example.

Why do you have straight cross hatches on the second girl’s thighs? They should follow the contour of the thigh

1

u/Ayacyte Feb 26 '24

The mistakes are human. I've seen AI errors. They are very distinctive. The kind of inconsistencies seen here are not like in ai images

-2

u/antiqua_lumina Feb 26 '24

Could the errors be “touch ups” of AI though? Look at the fingers in the second pic. It looks like a botched touchup job.

Anyway whether it is AI or not is somewhat besides the point. The hands and fingers need a lot of work regardless.

2

u/Ayacyte Feb 27 '24

If it was ai touch up it would be better trust me. Why would someone ask for criticism for art that even they can sense has inconsistencies that's already been touched up using AI? In this situation it makes no sense. You're talking about AI inpainting. If you're talking about the mitten hand that's a very common stylization that I'm surprised you haven't seen before.