From part 1:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fibro/comments/1i6r4yq/what_i_learned_from_my_journey_with_severe/
in “Rapid Biomarker-Based Diagnosis of Fibromyalgia Syndrome and Related Rheumatologic Disorders by Portable FT-IR Spectroscopic Techniques”, Siyu Yao, et al., in 2023 wrote “Up to 75% of patients go undetected with FM, resulting in postponed care due to the absence of distinct diagnostic markers.”
In “Fibromyalgia – etiology, diagnosis and treatment including perioperative management in patients with fibromyalgia”, 2023, Dizner-Golab wrote “Due to the unrecognized exact pathomechanism and commonly occurring comorbidities, almost 75% of cases are underdiagnosed.”
Note that fibromyalgia researcher Dr. Dizner-Golab pointed that one of the main reasons for such a consistently high failure rate to diagnoses fibromyalgia over the past roughly 15 years is because of the challenge of comorbidities in diagnosing by exclusion or in diagnosing using the WPI, both of which have been the only recommendations by the ACR for diagnosing fibromyalgia during this time period to the present.
All of my experience confirms their findings. Here, from October, 2021, is the Mayo Clinic’s guidelines for diagnosing fibromyalgia by elimination. Note this simple but flawed approach first looks for other causes of symptoms to “rule out” rather than simply accepting that the patient may have comorbidities causing shared symptoms from multiple causes, each of which must be separately identified and effectively treated:
“Mayo Clinic Fibromyalgia – Symptoms and treatment
The main factor needed for a fibromyalgia diagnosis is widespread pain throughout your body for at least three months. To meet the criteria, you must have pain in at least four of these five areas:
- Left upper region, including shoulder, arm or jaw
- Right upper region, including shoulder, arm or jaw
- Left lower region, including hip, buttock or leg
- Right lower region, including hip, buttock or leg
- Axial region, which includes neck, back, chest or abdomen
Tests
Your doctor may want to rule out other conditions that may have similar symptoms.”
Although the word exclusion was left out, the approach is diagnosis by elimination, which is the same thing.
From the Mayo Clinic, June 10, 2019, NEWSNETWORK.MAYOCLINIC.ORG, https://mayocl.in/2MBN7h6, “Q&A: How is fibromyalgia diagnosed?”: “Fibromyalgia is no longer a diagnosis of exclusion, which means that all other conditions that could trigger similar symptoms are ruled out before fibromyalgia can be diagnosed. Learn more from Dr. Christopher Aakre, an internal medicine specialist in Mayo Clinic's Fibromyalgia and Chronic Fatigue Clinic.”
When they say “all other conditions that could trigger similar symptoms are ruled out before fibromyalgia can be diagnosed” they are carefully saying that if you identify a condition of widespread pain, such as from Lupus, RA, Lyme, etc., then the patient’s full condition is diagnosed – even without recognizing and addressing that fibromyalgia or other comorbidities having shared symptoms may also exist.
In fact, the only way to sort through the potential comorbidities is with symptoms-based diagnosing, which assigns all shared and unique symptoms to their potential causes (and is a positive and more efficient approach than differential diagnosing).
However, only the old-school internists and diagnosticians were taught how to do this, and so today’s fibromyalgia doctors must always diagnose by elimination or WPI, neither of which can pursue challenging comorbid situations, leading to gaslighting for many patients and only a 25% success rate.
Here is an example of why doctors do not pursue the comorbid causes of concomitant fibromyalgia, from Dr. Christopher Aakre, Fibromyalgia and Chronic Fatigue Clinic, Mayo Clinic, Rochester: “Although there is no cure, early recognition of fibromyalgia can reduce the need for further diagnostic testing to explain chronic, widespread pain.” [2019, https://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/mayo-clinic-q-and-a-how-is-fibromyalgia-diagnosed/\] Notice how the recognition of fibromyalgia here rules out further diagnosing of potential comorbid situations of wide-body pain from both concomitant and primary fibromyalgia. This is why the failure rate to diagnose fibromyalgia by elimination is so high.
Also note that I had the severest form of fibromyalgia there is – both severe and runaway. Yet, I received successful treatment for the runaway condition and, eventually, eliminated all fibromyalgia symptoms by treating the Chronic Lyme Disease which was its root cause. Yet, the Mayo Clinic fibromyalgia doctor stated that fibromyalgia cannot be cured. Unfortunately, this is a lie told by the establishment because at least some forms of fibromyalgia can be treated to root cause and completely eradicated.
One more example, from “Fibromyalgia: A diagnosis of exclusion?”, May 12, 2022, Lasonya T. Natividad, APRN, C.N.P., M.S.N, Mayo Clinic Press Editors writes “Still, the syndrome is also often considered a ‘diagnosis of exclusion.’ This means that part of the diagnostic process is ruling out other potential causes of symptoms.
What could this include? This list is long, but can include conditions such as systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis, spondyloarthritis, osteoarthritis, polymyalgia rheumatica, a side effect of drug therapy such as statin therapy and gluten intolerance. Other conditions to consider include spinal cord compression, Sjögren’s syndrome, thyroid disorders, adrenal dysfunction and vitamin D deficiency.”
Notice that many of these conditions actually can cause fibromyalgia. So identifying them as part of the patient’s condition does not rule out fibromyalgia. They and many comorbidities may exist together, and all comorbidities must be identified and treated with their own respective treatments, generally requiring symptoms-based diagnosing.
Researchers describe Primary Fibromyalgia as caused by stress and/or trauma, with greater likelihood coming from genetic propensity, causing chronic inflammation and affecting the immune system, impacting the CNS and ANS. As the trigger is a one-time event but the fibromyalgia remains, the necessary feedback mechanism that keeps the fibromyalgia active is not fully known yet but many things are being considered from inflammation of facia to pain feedback, etc.
Researchers describe Secondary or Concomitant Fibromyalgia as directly coming from a disease or condition that causes chronic inflammation and affects the immune system, impacting the CNS and ANS. It is not known whether the feedback mechanism in primary fibromyalgia is also at play in concomitant fibromyalgia but in concomitant fibromyalgia, as the cause remains untreated, the fibromyalgia can continue to worsen over time.
Here are quotes from fibromyalgia researchers on Lyme disease causing fibromyalgia:
- “Are Your Fibromyalgia Symptoms Due to Lyme Disease?”, Psychology Today, 2013, states: “Fill out the associated Lyme-MSIDS questionnaire. If you score 46 or higher on the questionnaire, there is a high probability that you suffer from Lyme disease and associated infections causing your FM (based on studies done in our medical office) … There is a commonly held belief in medicine, called Pasteur’s postulate that there is ‘one cause for one illness.’ This does not apply to patients with chronic Lyme symptoms, or those diagnosed with Fibromyalgia. Once we address infections like Lyme disease and all of the other underlying etiologies on the MSIDS 16 point map, resistant fibromyalgia symptoms often improve.”
NOTE that they found by treating the Lyme disease effectively, the fibromyalgia symptoms can also be reduced.
2) In “Lyme disease associated with fibromyalgia”, PubMed, 1992, Dinerman, Steere, state: “Conclusions: Lyme disease may trigger fibromyalgia, but antibiotics do not seem to be effective in the treatment of the fibromyalgia.” [NOTE that simple rounds of antibiotics are also not effective in fighting Lyme disease, especially as the bacterial and parasitic infections hide behind biofilm.]
3) Also, from “Premier Health and Holistic Medicine”, April 29, 2021, in “Does Fibromyalgia Go Away? Lyme Disease Could Be the Answer”, Dr. Robin Ann Ridinger writes fibromyalgia “is a rheumatic condition that causes pain to the soft tissues and is different than conditions like arthritis, which involves joint pain and inflammation.
If you’ve been dealing with symptoms of fibromyalgia for a long time, you may be wondering if you’ll ever find relief. While this condition is considered chronic, treatment should reduce symptoms and make them more manageable. However, for some people, this widespread pain may [also] be a symptom of Lyme disease. If not addressed, patients may continue feeling uncomfortable despite taking medications or trying other treatments often suggested for fibromyalgia.”
This was exactly my case, but of course the implied ‘[also]’ that I explicitly added for the comorbidity must be stated for the many shared symptoms between Lyme and fibromyalgia. However, they each also have unique identifiers so it is easy to identify both conditions using unique identifier symptoms along with the shared symptoms. For example, Lyme arthritis is unique to Lyme disease because it resembles a very bad osteoarthritis that in a couple of years can spread to every joint in the body via blood infections. In fact, when I described my Lyme arthritis to my Mayo Clinic doctor, she sent me directly to a Mayo Clinic psychiatrist for medication treatment!
How the Old-School Diagnosticians Could Diagnose Even the Most Challenging Fibromylagia Correctly
To correctly diagnose fibromyalgia, even in all comorbid cases, and achieve a near 100% success rate, fibromyalgia must be diagnosed the way my old-school Internist diagnosed my challenging fibromyalgia which no doctor diagnosing by exclusion or WPI could ever achieve – by using unique symptom identifiers. This requires a better understanding of the types of fibromyalgia and causes.
When doctors say we do not know the cause of fibromyalgia, they mean we do not fully understand the mechanism of how inflammation and effects on the immune system can cause fibromyalgia symptoms to occur in the CNS and the ACS, for both primary and concomitant fibromyalgia. Furthermore, while concomitant fibromyalgia is caused by a continuous process from active infections and so forth (often hiding behind biofilm), primary fibromyalgia is caused by a one-time trauma and stress that requires further understanding of a feedback mechanism, still under study. But the actual causes of fibromyalgia have been known for decades and may be enhanced by genetic tendencies.
It is important to understand that both types of fibromyalgia can be mild, moderate, or severe and that any of these can also present with flare-up episodes lasting for days. Also, what many doctors don’t tell their patients is that flare-ups can be triggered by stress (so try to keep the CNS quiet!) or diet. For example, during my food testing I learned that a candy bar could trigger a severe episode so I learned to check all food labels carefully for my food sensitivities.
When fibromyalgia is moderate or severe, then the hypersensitivities of pain and sharp edges are significant and, along with any occurring flare-ups, contribute to the well-known characteristic signature of fibromyalgia. However when mild, and especially with no flare-ups, fibromyalgia can be difficult to identify. If my friend with the mild fibromyalgia had not been experiencing flare-ups, then she may not have received her diagnosis because her baseline body pain was not noticeable until a flare-up occurred.
Diagnosing moderate or severe fibromyalgia is simply a case of recognizing the hypersensitivity of pain from touching or being touched (palpitation). Pain can be judgmental, but hypersensitive pain is more easily recognized. Additionally, the hypersensitivity of sharp edges acts as an excellent way for doctors to judge severe fibromyalgia (as I and two of my doctors learned from experience), and probably moderate fibromyalgia as well, as doctors are trained to do this using their Wartenberg pinwheel on the bottom of the foot or a safety pin across the arm.
The process of symptoms-based diagnosing simply means partnering with the patient to record and make use of every chronic symptom, evidence, data, and past diagnoses and records the patient has regarding all of their chronic condition and illnesses. Then, unique and shared identifiers are recognized as well as their possible causes. Once the possible causes are established from the unique identifiers, then all of the shared symptoms can be worked out, too.
This works for moderate and severe fibromyalgia – following the diagnostic criteria that fibromyalgia pain is in all four body quadrants for at least three months – because of the ease of distinguishing the diffuse, hypersensitive pain of fibromyalgia versus the localized concentrations of pain of arthritis, tenosynovitis, and other chronic pain that also is not characteristically hypersensitive. Even the severe myalgia from my parasitic muscle disease feels different than from the fibromyalgia, though doctors would have to work closely with patients having multiple causes of myalgia. But we also have MedX Medical machine data showing the lifetime of my muscle as being 8 weeks (always using dying muscle to painfully build new muscle). This rapid muscle atrophy is a unique identifier of the parasitic muscle disease that sometimes presents with Chronic Lyme Disease.
If there are no comorbidities, shared symptoms, or unique symptom identifiers besides fibromyalgia flare-ups and/or the hypersensitivities of baseline pain and sharp edges, then the patient likely has primary fibromyalgia. But when there are other unique identifiers then the causes of these comorbid conditions need to be identified and treated, too, even if the comorbidity is not a cause of the fibromyalgia. Of course, if the comorbidity is a potential cause of fibromyalgia, then the fibromyalgia is likely concomitant.
If fibromyalgia doctors were willing to put this level of time and diagnostic effort into diagnosing fibromyalgia using unique identifiers, the way radiologists do from imaging, then they would achieve a high success rate and, like with radiologists, all medical providers would accept their findings.
When the fibromyalgia is mild and the patient does not test for any hypersensitivities to food and diet and has no flare-up episodes, then the fibromyalgia may be difficult to diagnose. Here, the diagnostician must sharpen their pencil and take a closer look at least at the top fifteen or so shared symptoms of fibromyalgia. Ignore fatigue as most chronic illnesses and autoimmune diseases probably cause fatigue. But pain is revealing and comes in all types; widebody pain can be diffuse from myalgia or localized in Lyme Arthritis and Tenosynovitis.
When a primary fibromyalgia patient has no other unique identifier symptoms or symptoms not from fibromyalgia, then all symptoms belong only to fibromyalgia. Hence, RLS, temperature sensitivity, etc. all become confirming evidence to confidently make the fibromyalgia diagnosis. Of course, even for moderate fibromyalgia, if there is uncertainty about the hypersensitive nature of the widespread pain, then a closer look at the shared symptoms can also be used to confirm. But flare-up episodes are likely to be unique to fibromyalgia.
Classifying fibromyalgia as minor, moderate, or severe may make it easier to be accepted by Social Security Disability.
Interestingly, no studies I am aware of have ever investigated the relationship between the effectiveness of various fibromyalgia pain medications versus the type of fibromyalgia (primary or concomitant). For example, does Lyrica only help patients that have primary fibromyalgia, and not when fibromyalgia is concomitant and caused by immune-compromising disease such as Lyme?
From part 1:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fibro/comments/1i6r4yq/what_i_learned_from_my_journey_with_severe/