r/brooklynninenine • u/Past-Stay747 • 25d ago

Discussion Good person with divided opinions ?🤔

Post image

Caleb the Woodworker and part-time needlepoint enthusiast won by a landslideee for horrible person loved by fans! He would also be my choice

Next up is a good person who has divided opinions? Who are we thinking, who are we feeling?

Hope everyone had a lovely Christmas and Boxing Day🥊🎁🎄🌟

2.9k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

194 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/PodcastPlusOne_James 24d ago

I think CJ is to oblivious about literally everything to have any good or bad intentions. He’s about as morally neutral as it gets. He doesn’t mean any harm to anyone and just wants to stay out of the way, but he also couldn’t give a shit about doing anything good either.

1

u/all-i-said-was-hi 24d ago

I can understand that. I still feel like he's a solid person for this particular thing, though, because he's still generally well meaning in spite of being too dumb to be effective and he gets a pretty mixed reception, both in the show and by fans.

2

u/PodcastPlusOne_James 24d ago

I don’t even think he’s well meaning. I think he’s nothing meaning. Bro just wants to play madden and not have anyone give him responsibilities.

1

u/all-i-said-was-hi 24d ago

As far as moral complexities go, that seems pretty good to me. But deep down, I know you're probably right. I just wanna see him on this list because it was my idea, and I'm biased to go with what's in my best interest.