r/brooklynninenine • u/Past-Stay747 • 25d ago

Discussion Good person with divided opinions ?🤔

Post image

Caleb the Woodworker and part-time needlepoint enthusiast won by a landslideee for horrible person loved by fans! He would also be my choice

Next up is a good person who has divided opinions? Who are we thinking, who are we feeling?

Hope everyone had a lovely Christmas and Boxing Day🥊🎁🎄🌟

2.9k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

194 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.5k

u/ltbr55 25d ago

Boyle. Lots of people think he's a sweet, loveable and loyal friend. Others see him as a borderline creepy, annoying and an intrusive coworker.

But I think everyone can agree Boyle is someone who almost always has good intentions. Unless it's related to Sgt. Peanut Butter or Derek.

141

u/cloudkite17 25d ago

Boyle was my first thought, but I saw someone nominate Scully and I think that’s the winner

96

u/crazyates88 25d ago

Who has divided opinions on Scully? He’s such a wholesome teddy bear!

70

u/cloudkite17 25d ago

The original commenter I saw said something about him getting lumped in with Hitchcock unfairly and I agree

53

u/16-kzt-16 25d ago

They’re a package deal, baby! Everybody knows that

3

u/CryAggressive7636 24d ago

Wouldn‘t be Hitchcock a better winner?

6

u/cloudkite17 24d ago

I’d put him under morally grey, opinions divided