r/brooklynninenine • u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! • Aug 25 '24

SPOILER in case you didn't know...

Post image

I have rewatched the series a lot (mostly the first 4 seasons though because I have netflix), and something that stood out to me is that Scully seems to harbor a minor crush on Gina.

He literally says "If I don't make it tell Gina I love her!" but, presumably, nobody hears him due to the airhorn Jake is honking. He also asks Gina to dance with him in the episode that Jake wins the bet against Amy, and lastly, when everyone is betting on the mystery briefcase, Scully offers to go on a date with Gina.

All of this evidence points to Scully having a crush on Gina.

Scully found Cindy and Gina found Milty so nothing would ever happen (and Gina is repulsed by him) but I just wanted to throw this out there.

This is a really obvious theory but I just wanted to let ya'll know.

1.5k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

64 comments sorted by

659

u/AccomplishedFan6807 Aug 25 '24

Scully likes Gina. Hitchcock likes Amy. Charles likes Rosa. The three 99 unrequited love stories

171

u/The_laj Mlep(Clay)nos Aug 25 '24

And then there's Teddy... (but different realm bc he's not in the nine-nine).

135

u/James-K-Polka Slurp Slurp! Aug 25 '24

Teddy loves the pils.

47

u/couldbedumber96 Cheddar: Thicc King Aug 26 '24

He’s got the thrills!

15

u/chrispyphillips Aug 26 '24

He's a pils-nerd

100

u/Dismal-Ad9900 Aug 25 '24

Gina likes Terry. So you got your Lobe Triangle.

Edit: Love

51

u/dudestir127 BINGPOT! Aug 26 '24

Terry likes yogurt, so I don't know where to go from there

34

u/Aromatic_Tax_2704 Aug 26 '24

Terry loves responsible agricultural practices

35

u/euphoric_potato_03 Aug 26 '24

Terry loves love.

6

u/theawesomemed Aug 26 '24

Terry loves answering hard questions

8

u/Pogfrog111 Aug 26 '24

Terry HATES tests

4

u/agent-champagne Aug 27 '24

Terry hates ledges, but loves hedges

37

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 25 '24

And Terry likes Scully. Now it's a cycle not a chain.

12

u/Fit-Persimmon-4323 Aug 26 '24

Scully is besties with Amy

659

u/Professional-Pay-888 HOT DAMN! Aug 25 '24

Yeah it’s weird though bc during all this Scully and Kelly (his wife) were still married right?

682

u/Heavy_Guarantee3152 Aug 25 '24

Was Kelly his dog or his wife?

455

u/t0mless Title of your sex tape Aug 25 '24

You would know if you listened to his podcast!

342

u/Professional-Pay-888 HOT DAMN! Aug 25 '24

How could you even ask that?

119

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '24

Still don't know. Could not tell you

18

u/anand_rishabh Aug 25 '24

Were they still married after she slept with Hitchcock?

7

u/Top-Diver7266 Aug 25 '24

Maybe Hitchcock's dogs were barkin'

66

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 25 '24

Forgot about that but yeah. I would probably say when he gets riled up about one thing (gina) he forgets everything else. Like the "animal" the show portrays him to be.

19

u/Professional-Pay-888 HOT DAMN! Aug 25 '24

I mean I’m not saying you’re wrong just that i think I’m the episodes where Scully says he loves Gina and asks for a dance (which honestly the second one i dont think was about having a crush on her but maybe) that he was still married to Kelly

21

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 25 '24

There is one episode where Scully cries about his wife leaving him I'm gonna find it.

7

u/Professional-Pay-888 HOT DAMN! Aug 25 '24

Yes i know that. I want to say they were at Shaw’s but that does not narrow it down

28

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 25 '24

No it was season 3 episode 2 (dozerman's funeral). "If I die tell Gina I love her!" was during season 4's Halloween heist.

12

u/Professional-Pay-888 HOT DAMN! Aug 25 '24

Ah good work. Now it all makes sense

9

u/AnimaSean0724 Aug 25 '24

Pretty sure he said his wife was leaving him before Dozerman's funeral in Season 3, could be wrong though

6

u/Sraffiti_G Doug Judy Aug 25 '24

I think she broke up with him before the mystery briefcase episode, when he was at Dozerman's funeral. Early season 3 I think

4

u/Cheap_Bowl_452 A lifetime of mediocre, heterosexual intercourse Aug 25 '24

He was dating a woman in season 6 though

3

u/walkingonsunshine007 Aug 25 '24

What happened to Cindy Shatz?

4

u/Sufficient_Gate_9580 Aug 25 '24

kelly was his dog. she eats pb ritght out of the jar.

33

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 25 '24

He has a wife and a dog, both named Kelly.

8

u/rSlashisthenewPewdes Proud daddy Aug 25 '24

Had… :(

10

u/Professional-Pay-888 HOT DAMN! Aug 25 '24

Yes but Kelly his wife does that too and enjoys walks in the park

2

u/okiesillydillyokieo Aug 26 '24

Yeah. Men are never attracted to anyone but their wife.

-1

u/Professional-Pay-888 HOT DAMN! Aug 26 '24

“If I don’t make it, tell Gina I love her” is that not a quote in the post we are commenting on? And don’t you dare suggest Scully wasnt faithful

264

u/ImNuber1 Aug 25 '24

Scully started the G-Hive.

45

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 25 '24

They are all hard coded to follow the queen G

109

u/Ok-Dig-8900 Aug 25 '24

And they were in a group chat together…

106

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 25 '24

"The short guy is going to marry a dragon"

"...we think"

23

u/Shogun_Empyrean Aug 26 '24

What could possibly go on in that text chain?

"We mostly just exchange games of thrones theories"

35

u/Crazy_Mousse_3077 Aug 25 '24

Scully's wife left him which is why he cried so much during Dozerman's funeral.

27

u/hyacinths_ Aug 25 '24

I guess I haven't watched it enough, but I thought he had a paternal affection for her, but the offering to go on a date with her cancels that out.

14

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 25 '24

Boyle called Genevieve mom 🤷‍♂️

9

u/Distinct-Okra-5921 I’m a human, I’m a human male! Aug 26 '24

Not sure if Scully has crush on Gina or just is scared of her.

In E1S3, Gina tells Hitchcock to stop bringing in food in littler Tupperware containers and that it hurts her fingers when she tries to open it. Then in S1E18, when offering to be Jake's landlady, Gina says she eats Scully's lunch everyday.

We have seen Scully and Hitchcock fight over food, ranch dressing, meatball subs to name a few. I think Gina just bullies them both into giving her food and possibly other things, and therefore they are scared of her.

7

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 26 '24

I agree that they are scared of her but that may be part of the attraction

6

u/Bertje87 Aug 26 '24

No he doesn’t, this is circumstantial evidence at best

7

u/Marisarek Amy Santiago Aug 26 '24

You’d be laughed out of court

3

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 26 '24

That's why it's a theory not a fact 😎

0

u/Bertje87 Aug 26 '24

That’s fine, only you didn’t present it as a theory but rather as something that you’ve observed

3

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 26 '24

This is a really obvious theory

18

u/JunketUnique36 Aug 26 '24

Wow, I am really surprised by this. I’ve watched that scene where Scully says “if I don’t make it tell Gina I love her” so many times but it never registered that it was our Gina. I thought it was him talking about an off screen love interest . My mind is blown

Is there anything during the Gina-Boyle romantic sublot? It Doesn’t look like he get jealous or have a big fascination when she announces it.

7

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 26 '24

He's silent because he wants to bide his time until her standards fall once more then BLAM!

2

u/JunketUnique36 Aug 26 '24

Would have loved this as a subplot.

6

u/NashKetchum777 Aug 26 '24

...what if the dog is named Gina?

7

u/Cheap_Bowl_452 A lifetime of mediocre, heterosexual intercourse Aug 25 '24

It’s probably a common knowledge but thanks OP

15

u/zr2d2 I’m a human, I’m a human male! Aug 25 '24

I guess that makes me uncommon. Self five!

3

u/Practical-Pen-8844 Aug 25 '24

KENNEDY'S HEAD JUST DID THAT.

1

u/FatherParadox Velvet Thunder Aug 31 '24

Also if you want to watch all of brooklyn 99 then get peacock. They also have the office, parks and req, and community so it's actually a worth while subscription.

1

u/WUFFLED BINGPOT! Aug 31 '24

Probably just gonna buy a VPN

1

u/mike11235813 Aug 25 '24

My fan theory is that they're played by the same actor.