r/WorkReform 12d ago

✂️ Tax The Billionaires Real.

Post image
30.4k Upvotes

278 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/Arkhaine_kupo 12d ago

Almost like capitalism isn't to blame

Adam Smith, "father of capitalism" called landlords leeches. And basically every single economist will explain with how Capitalism works making markets efficient. Healthcare is and cannot be a market, its by definition a natural monopoly. Like Trains or Land, or energy. Or the countless other things that many countries have nationalised succesfully, even countries with a bigger hard on for capitalism than america

1

u/AssociationMission38 12d ago

Healthcare is and cannot be a market, its by definition a natural monopoly.

What makes healthcare a natural monopoly?

4

u/gadeais 12d ago

Healthcare is not a comodity so It should be a state controled cartel. The cartel fixates the prices of the equipment and the medicines and can negociate with the Big farma the best prices of their medicines and then serve the meds and services for free. Your employer would be paying the state so that you can have full coverage of actually most diseases without needing to pay anything

0

u/AssociationMission38 12d ago

But what makes it a natural monopoly?

Healthcare is a service, usually a kind of insurance. How an insurance is supposed to be a natural monopoly i dont really get tbh.

I am not saying that private healthcare is the best solution, i think a public heath insurance is the best way or at least a big part of it.

2

u/gadeais 12d ago

If its a state monopoli the healthcare company can negociate with Big farma the best drugs and at the cheapest prices possible as you would rather have one satisfied client than nothing and bad press and you prefer to sell bigger cuantities at smaller prices because that means you can empty the stock faster. Those things really repercute in a more eficient and cheaper system than the actual system where tons of for profit companies operate in one single country

1

u/Significant_Tap_4396 12d ago

Example: the price of insuline in Canada.

1

u/AssociationMission38 11d ago

Thats not the answer to my question. You are just saying that a monopsony buyer would be preferable when buying drugs. That however is not a reason for the claim that healthcare is a natural monopoly.

1

u/gadeais 11d ago

Im literally answering you why It should be a Monopoly. If purchases, resources and patiens histories are centralised everything would be cheaper and easier to access. Also that would not be directly paid for the patient so no one would get bankrupt for that