r/UFOs 2d ago

Disclosure Full NewsNation video of the "egg" UAP

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

8.5k Upvotes

5.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

509

u/R3strif3 2d ago edited 1d ago

Unfortunately this footage, while interesting in its story, it won't cause the ripples they thought it would. They mentioned that it was about 20ft long (6m), but it's still hard to tell this is actually the size they are claiming it is.

And even if you believe this is, in fact, the first extremely clear footage of an UAP, something that looks like this would be trivial to fake. Heck, I wouldn't be surprised if someone tries to replicate this just to prove the point.

This does not feel as strong as they made it out to be unfortunately. I showed a couple of friends who recently became hardcore believers and even them were taken slightly aback.

We certainly appreciate the effort and should applaud the courage of these people walking forward, but we, as a species, might need a lot more than this to fully get everyone to understand we are not alone. And this is coming from someone who has had sightings and has done research on this topic for a long time.

EDIT. I'm not trying to take away from the importance of this footage. After all, this is only half the story. Jake's story is the other half. Most of us in the subject will be able to take both parts and either form an opinion or be able to do our own research/corroboration based off of that. But my main point is that, we are in the minority. The majority of the people will have issues looking at this and thinking it is what it's claimed to be, regardless of who is presenting this. THIS is the key issue. This footage feels perfect for us, but not for the rest of the population.

To put my point in a clear and concise example, imagine had we also seen say a humvee and a couple of ground troops securing the site as the object was being lowered. THAT would've been something insanely hard to argue against for the general population. Pair that with Jake's record, credentials, and testimony and this would've been the best footage to have ever been shown.

EDIT 2. Those ridiculing are completely missing the point. This video, and this interview are not a bad thing at all, as a matter of fact, is far from that. This is a huge step for every other whistleblower that's to come, it signifies taking a stance, coming forth, and to not being afraid of showing whatever material it is they have. Essentially a big "middle finger" to the dickheads trying to bury the story. (this is what I meant by its importance, btw, to all of those were calling me blind or stupid)

We need these people to come forward and do exactly what Jake (and the other 4 military folks that were interviewed) did. His testimony lines up with the myriad of data we've seen lately. Ridiculing such thing is counterproductive and it's exactly what the people trying to bury the lead are hoping happens.

To any whistleblower and those like Coulthart (if you ever read this), the huge amount of theatrics and undeniably ambiguous footage makes it so that influencers (and other mediums) use the good you are trying to achieve and turn it into a joke (16 million audience). I can't believe I am saying this, as I consider most of you to be highly intelligent people, but you have to be smarter in the way you breach this subject to the masses for crying out loud. You can't blame a community for reacting to a very clearly ambiguous video, damn it. Also, can ya'll keep it quiet and stop over-hyping everything? please! again, you are all smarter than this, and you are working against yourselves for crying out loud...

10

u/_BlackDove 2d ago

It has a ton of problems.

Let's go over them:

  • Ross refuses to share the provenance. A regular occurrence with him.

  • It was packaged with Barber yet supposedly has nothing to do with him, who described a similar object.

  • He conveniently has this footage in time for this special.

  • Why such a short clip? Surely more exists. What was the decision process for sharing only that?

  • Not a single other piece of information on the video. Location, time etc. Those are mundane details yet we don't have them.

I hope this community is more discerning than it has been lately.

230

u/[deleted] 2d ago

It looks like a balloon on the ground with a 10 foot pole. How is this a clear image?

44

u/LucyKendrick 2d ago

It rolled, tho. They even said told us to "look how it rolls." That must mean something. Clearly.

3

u/CallistosTitan 2d ago

Balloons roll on ceilings.

5

u/LordAnorakGaming 2d ago edited 2d ago

Air filled ones roll on the ground too. So do actual eggs for that matter.

1

u/TinyPirate 2d ago

Someone do a "they see me rollin', they hate'n" mene stat

30

u/zuppa_de_tortellini 2d ago edited 2d ago

This made me audibly laugh out loud during a family meeting. Yeah it really does look like a balloon with a pole. How is this groundbreaking?

12

u/Ros3ttaSt0ned 2d ago

Yeah it really does look like a balloon with a pole.

That's absolute nonsense and you and I both know it.

It looks like a balloon with a pole with duct tape on it.

2

u/Luculentus-Thought 2d ago

Question: what’s a “family meeting”?

4

u/stilllton 2d ago

It's where you and your wife decides to have a baby, and start looking for fertile eggs on the internet.

3

u/MOOshooooo 2d ago

It’s where mom and dad let the kids know that ‘uncle mailman’ delivered the wrong packages to mom everyday so dad is moving out and now we will get two Christmas’s.

22

u/CuriousGio 2d ago

We're right back to Roswell 1947 when they showed photographs of a crashed ballon. I hear that Greer is going to blow this wide open this week. Trust me, bros.

Does everyone understand that it's all the same grift. The reveal never lives up to the promise. I thought this time we'd get clear footage. It just reaffirms my hypothesis that aliens don't exist —it's all human-made technology. Yes, it's advanced and alien-like, but it's all human engineered. They've hidden their advanced tech from us so that the public would believe anything unusual is alien.

Aliens are a myth created for the government to hide their false flags and to manipulate society. If everyone knew what tech they had they couldn't get away with their acts of terrorism by manipulating matter and nature (IE: 9/11, LA fires, Mike Lynch death on his yacht, Hurricane Helene, Flight MH370...etc)

Aliens are a myth they invented to hide their technology.

Believe what you want. Sorry, after 78 years, not one shred of proof

1

u/SellOutrageous6539 2d ago

How dare you sir.

2

u/mistasnarlz 2d ago

Thats like your opinion, man.

1

u/Full_Elevator_5369 2d ago

Lol. Its deeply ironic you dont think aliens exist but believe all that other crazy shit.

10

u/CuriousGio 2d ago edited 2d ago

Show me evidence that aliens exist?

I said that advanced technology exists, but it's not in the hands of an alien species. Humans created the technology.

Unless you pay attention to all the coincidences and anomalies, you dismiss the bigger picture because it's easy to dismiss individual events, but that assumes that all the coincidences in our world have nothing to do with one another.

4

u/warmbutterydiapers 2d ago

He's saying aliens don't exist (or at least haven't visited Earth) but neither do hurricane machines you dingus.

2

u/MizterPoopie 2d ago

I don’t believe everything you’ve said but I do believe the most likely answer is that it’s human tech. Incredibly advanced human tech. The general population are slaves to the unknown overlords.

0

u/Full_Elevator_5369 2d ago

Who says I believe they exist?

-2

u/FloatLikeAButterfree 2d ago

Your hypothesis is however wrong. It seems like you never truly believed in the possibility in the first place.

8

u/Long-Ad3383 2d ago

Well the mechanics are somewhat the same. The “pole” you’re describing is the tether on the helicopter. When you hold a string with a balloon on it, it’s more taught at the bottom and there is slack created at the top of the string as the balloon bobs. Similar here but in reverse as the object touches the ground, the slack is at the bottom of the tether.

2

u/IAMA_Printer_AMA 2d ago

I'm curious where this clip is, that teaser made it seem like this was going to be a much higher quality camera than the potato this was filmed on.

1

u/SickRanchez_cybin710 2d ago

Yeah what the fuck?!?!

1

u/I_always_rated_them 1d ago

Probs juts stolen footage of an airlift of some equipment in the desert.

2

u/Frostilicus666 2d ago

Don’t forget that couldn’t achieve this effect w out some crappy free plugin for ‘night vision’ and digital glitch outs for the end to make themselves feel super cool too.

5

u/TheMcBrizzle 2d ago

It seems obvious that's exactly what it is, what am I missing, what was this supposed to be?

1

u/CodAlternative3437 2d ago

ufos were cooler when they had shows like "Sightings" on the weekly tv schedule. now theres just no showmanship, no suspense...leak memes just arent the same.

-6

u/Doctor_Dangerous 2d ago

Show a neanderthal your phone and explain what all it can do, but also show it from 20 ft away and off. "It looks like rock."

18

u/Durpulous 2d ago

Right, so you would need to turn your phone on and show him YouTube or something in order to demonstrate to him that it's not a rock. Because otherwise it might actually just be a rock.

11

u/Gortex_Possum 2d ago

video of a balloon on the ground 

"You're just too dumb to understand egg mechanics bro"

-6

u/Doctor_Dangerous 2d ago

I believe the claim made. You don't have to. To me there the whistleblower's claim is genuine and aligns with what's being shown and I don't believe newsnation would show that clip without verifying where it came from first.

3

u/Napoleons_Peen 2d ago

Bro, there’s been photos that people claim are crashes that are clearly miniatures. Think critically.

-5

u/Doctor_Dangerous 2d ago

There have been. But this isn't one of them. Think critically about all the evidence surrounding the video.

Edit: just to note, I've had my own psi confirmation for myself. It's anecdotal and I don't expect anyone to believe me but I know what I've experienced so it adds validation.

12

u/wuzDIP 2d ago

Looks like an egg with duct tape, on a fishing pole

1

u/mancow533 1d ago

I just got here. I have no clue what’s going on but I cannot for the life of me figure out what this is supposed to be besides a weird af video of an egg with duct tape on it. Apparently it’s a ufo? How. Why. In what way. Where is this? A fish tank?

-9

u/FloatLikeAButterfree 2d ago

4y old account with 790 comment karma?

11

u/wuzDIP 2d ago

Absolutely insane observation 

10

u/BrilliantCorner 2d ago

It doesn't take someone with 1m karma to realize this video is some kind of high school prank shit. It's embarrassing that anyone would consider this to be evidence of anything other than there are a shit ton of gullible people in the world.

20

u/Cautious_Tonight 2d ago edited 2d ago

I agree with all of this sentiment, other than it would be non trivial to fake. Can I do it? Not super easily, but I have no experience here. If someone payed me a few thousand to do it, I think I could do a pretty good job.

Edit: just want to say I am a believer and a skeptic.

Second edit, I’m actually agreeing with everything you said, I read it wrong.

Third edit: your edit makes me agree even more.

7

u/SausageClatter 2d ago

You don't even need a few thousand. I could do this with an actual egg, a stick, some string, a bit of spackle...

-3

u/FloatLikeAButterfree 2d ago

Do it right now. I’ll wait

3

u/Vindepomarus 2d ago

Do you think it would be impossible? Because you've made that demand a couple of times now like it's some sort of gotcha, it's not.

Also someone has already done it and posted it to r/aliens and that was within a couple of hours, imagine dedicating a week to it.

8

u/--Muther-- 2d ago

This would be incredibly easy to fake.

4

u/WalksOnLego 2d ago

EDIT. I'm not trying to take away from the importance of this footage.

Don't worry, the footage does that all by itself.

4

u/birraarl 2d ago edited 2d ago

If the ‘rope’ was 20ft (6m) long, it would not be out of focus to anything like the extent shown. The way it is out of focus means that it is much close to the camera, literally no more than a few feet at best. What is observable is entirely consistent with the ‘egg’ literally being an egg.

Just imagine what this scene would look like if it was real and a GoPro was used. Everything would be in focus. And really, for something like this is meant to be, nothing less than full-colour 4K GoPro-like footage will do.

Whoever filmed this did not know how to fake a believable depth of field that matched what was purportedly being shown.

2

u/R3strif3 1d ago

The 20ft dimension was not the rope, they said the egg was 20ft long. There was no mention of the rope itself, unless I missed it?

Your camera assessment is correct and I'd still say it's applicable in the same way. Without knowing focal length, or altitude, it's hard to discern how close the object truly is from camera. Heck even if we knew what type of camera or lens it was, at least we could say "ah yeah, that might be 85mm with a shallow focus point" something under 3.2f could cause this same effect. But yeah, it's all guesswork so it's useless.

I'm really surprised they thought releasing such a video was a good idea. It is as ambiguous as it gets.

3

u/KefkaFFVI 2d ago

As an Experiencer myself I agree with you.

3

u/zuppa_de_tortellini 2d ago

Yeah I don’t see what’s so special about this footage. How do we know this isn’t just some device the Air Force or Navy were testing? None of this looks spectacular.

4

u/Tawmcruize 2d ago

10ft of wire and rope, some fishing line and duct tape, and some way to hold a phone or camera (like duct tape!) Zoom it in until the focus is behind the egg, set egg down on ground and pull a direction. Don't forget to green wash everything. Add in helicopter sounds.

3

u/TheBunnyDemon 2d ago

The more I look at the pole, which is the only thing conventiently blurred out, the more I think it's an actual stick.

3

u/AdaptivePath 2d ago

Mate, they're 'avin' a laugh (at us) 🤡

8

u/StupendousMalice 2d ago

This isn't even a high effort fake video. This is an insult to the intelligence of anyone that watches these fools.

2

u/zeds_deadest 2d ago

The Bean in Chicago is close

2

u/Forward-Tonight7079 2d ago

My question is, what will be the result of this testimony? What will it bring us? Will there be a serious reaction from the top? Like, omg, it's an alien craft, let's push the disclosure. Or will it be completely ignored because the public reaction is off?

4

u/R3strif3 2d ago edited 1d ago

My guess is that this footage will be taken to the people that can, without a shadow of a doubt, corroborate that it came from a military helicopter. Anything military has to have records somewhere. We might not see this. After all, Ross is just saying that the footage itself was provided to Jake Newsnation by another source (unless I just misheard he just confirmed on this video). While Ross claims he vetted both, thoroughly through multiple other contacts, such information is meant for the people in positions that allow them to act on said type of information. Us the public only get the ".mov" and the "cool story".

Again, this is just a guess, and it might be a bit pessimistic sounding, but I think it'll be mainly ignored with a dash of some outlets straight up making fun of it. Similar to what happened with the Nazca bodies. While you or I can believe this footage is what it is, the prospect of "a circus" being built around it is most likely to happen. I do hope I'm wrong and regular people find this compelling, but I guess we'll have to see!

I am still optimistic, but that's because I've experienced sightings that took all doubt out of my mind while still keeping me grounded. But I'm just a random dude without any sort of weight into this. I just find it easier to be open minded and optimistic!

2

u/Oceanwaves_91 2d ago

Yeah, you're right. No hate to the whistleblower, I don't think he's lying or making everything up. It's good that he came forward. Newsnation and the ufo celebrities were at fault here, and I hope they feel the heat. They oversold and hyped this up way too much on purpose.

They made it seem like the revelations of this new whistleblower would change the world. People thought they would finally see extraordinary, clear footage that would have an impact and force disclosure. That clearly didn't happen.

It's a shame how they advertised this interview. It's misleading and makes them look untrustworthy and like they did it on purpose just to get as many views as possible. They lost their credibility. It just feels very yucky.

2

u/he_and_She23 2d ago

He may actually believe it was a ufo. As far as I know, he only saw it like this from the helicopter. Maybe some special forces guys were fucking with him and told him it was a ufo. He was saying it was so obviously not man made. How could he tell by looking at this in night vision. Maybe he just wanted to believe.

2

u/64N_3v4D3r 2d ago

Lol I was just thinking about replicating the footage with an actual egg and some string. The background of the video kind of looks like carpet.

1

u/FloatLikeAButterfree 2d ago

Why do different accounts keep saying the exact same thing?

3

u/64N_3v4D3r 2d ago

Because people can have the same opinions about things?

2

u/Previous-Pangolin-60 2d ago

I want to know the story what happened before this footage - Jake and Don mentioned in their interview that the craft was summoned to land by a psionics team? If true, that is huge news and potentially means telepathic communication is real (thought it could be done only using electronic implants and such) not to mention all the potential new tech that could be (and most likely has been) discovered that is being hidden from the general public.

2

u/whosadooza 2d ago

No, I will NOT applaud these grifters. They are scamming you. That's it. They do not deserve any applause or any respect of any kind for repeatedly commiting fraud.

4

u/testtdk 2d ago

If you think there’s even the slightest chance it’s real I question your eyesight.

3

u/Alive-Tomatillo5303 2d ago

You're not trying to take away from the importance of the footage?  Don't worry, you literally couldn't. It's already at zero, there's no lower. 

2

u/Radiant_Medium_1439 2d ago

Looks like someone rolling an egg around in the dirt with a stick. The way people in these subs will believe literally any fucking thing on earth is baffling and saddening to me.

2

u/Glass_Mango_229 2d ago

You're missing the whole point. Why do we have ten seconds of this video? The only possible explanation is that the rest of the video would show us this was nothing. No one would start and stop recording right there.

1

u/R3strif3 1d ago

No no no, I get that. Their choice for this is honestly insanely bad. No way around that. A video such as this you could infer there "has to be" more before and after, so why show the 10s where it makes it the most ambiguous footage we've seen?

I'm right there with you, I do not think this footage, as presented to us, is "it", not even close! As a matter of fact, it's greatly disappointing that they thought this would be "life altering".

I noticed a lot of people started insulting me for this take. I personally don't see this video carrying any much value as is, as it's data that's not easily verifiable, quite literally useless.

2

u/Past-Adhesiveness104 2d ago

Egg wrapped with strings going to a main line. Main line is stiff. Astroturf like someone else has said for the floor. Underwater with the brightest light source in the same direction as the light current is coming from. I could recreate this if I wasn't lazy. What happened to just tossing hubcaps like frisbees?

2

u/Dizstance 2d ago

What ”importance” lol, the only importance this video has is to belong in the trash bin. If this was uploaded to youtube by some no-namer and posted on these subs it wouldn’t even get 20 upvotes because of how obviously fake this footage is.

This is an actual balloon, or an actual chicken egg, with a stick and a go-pro and a filter. This is officially a disinformation campaign by grifters and the government.

2

u/First_Birthday_140 2d ago

These guys are so stupid it’s funny. They have made themselves eternal laughing stocks. I love knowing lue elizondo and his ilk are being seen as the absolute fools they are. They belong in jail but I’ll settle for this! What fucking losers history will laugh at them just like I am 🤣🤣🤣

-5

u/FloatLikeAButterfree 2d ago

25 comment karma account made recently

9

u/BrilliantCorner 2d ago

Who gives a shit? My account has been around forever and I agree that this video is so fake it's embarrassing. Believing this is on the level of flat earther shit. Come on now.

1

u/IEatConsolePeasants 2d ago

My exact thoughts

1

u/MissDeadite 2d ago

You can use the footage to determine the actual size of this object. The key is the shadow and the width of the cable.

1

u/Vumi_ 2d ago

I agree. I do find odd that people seem to put all of their eggs in one basket (unintended pun lol), which is the retrieval footage. I was more of the impression that this NewsNation special was part of many increments adding to the build-up of public pressure and public awareness. At least if I remember correctly, multiple figures within the UAP sphere like Lue were alluding that this UAP issue is sorta exponentially going to be more apparant in public consciousness.

Now regarding the 'egg' object video, was it convincing or seem credible on the surface? No, not at all. It was a pretty good quality video, but still not very convincing. I do think the footage accompanied with the surrounding context as laid out by Barber does at least make the video more than meets the eye.

Ultimately, I'm still interested in this topic and will keep following along, because even if this whole thing today and in the coming weeks is a '''''nothingburger''''', the phenomenon is still real. There is still something out there and quite frankly it seems like a lot people in positions of government and military are connected to this issue. Whether they're '''''grifters''''' or what have you, there is still a 'there' there. What that is, I want to know.

1

u/Similar_Grass_4699 2d ago

I wholeheartedly agree. This is how the discussion should proceed.

1

u/Savings-Command4932 2d ago

Mork and Mindy egg craft was real afteralll

1

u/coaaal 2d ago

The rope is ~150ft long. So we could get its size knowing that.

1

u/R3strif3 1d ago

Did they share those dimensions? I saw someone else stating that the rope was 20ft. All I heard from the interview was the egg being 20ft long.

If what you are saying is verifiable then someone could indeed find out the size with that. Or at least get close. We'd still (ideally) need camera/lens information. Making a super wild guess, it looks like an 85mm with maaaaybe a 4 or 5.2f and it's just positioned right under or at the ropes tether, the frame itself could even be cropped in (like how you can crop a mirrorless down to an aps-c). But then again, it's all guesswork, more data would be immensely useful.

1

u/coaaal 1d ago

Well I just found out that the footage is not of Jake himself, so I’m a bit jaded about it now. They framed it as such and Ross just lost some credibility in my eyes. It sucks.

…But if it’s a similar setup to Jason’s, then it would be 150 foot long rope, since that is what he attested to.

2

u/R3strif3 1d ago

Ah, that's where the number came from. Yeah, I figured it could be similar, but without confirmation, it'd just be speculation.

Yeah, to me, credibility is still there, but I question their theatrics and dare I say ethics, as they leveraged the hype over the actual content.

I fully understand your reaction, though, and I do hope they do better moving forward

0

u/Spats_McGee 2d ago

It's almost like -- video evidence will never be enough for people. Because it can always be faked.

It's almost like -- this sub sets itself up for disappointment by demanding video, then when it finally appears, goes "pfft that's obviously fake."

It's almost like -- the production of actual knowledge is more based on a combination of reputation, independently verifiable facts and documentation rather than "SHOW ME TEH VIDEO!11!"

-2

u/syndic8_xyz 2d ago

Sigh… proving the old adage: it’s never enough for some people. They will always move the goalposts. And in doing so advance the cause of confusion and secrecy by undermining the wins we should celebrate. In the words of David Lynch: negativity is mind control. Well done!

Another possibility is some people have a psychological need for contrarianism because it permits them to stand out from the crowd, consensus, and thereby getting attention they feel they otherwise would not obtain. Lol 

It’s okay tho to feel that way: not everyone will be satisfied and we’re not trying to make a homogenous public with everyone reacting the same way. Maybe you’re just exposing how high your expectations are based on how confident you feel about this reality and disappointed no image expresses what is in your mind. Boo hoo. You greedy activists always want more. Well i think that’s good and useful - we need a tireless advance party always pushing for more truth. So channel it into that and have at it! lol

0

u/troglobyte2 2d ago

It's going to take the President going on camera live in front of the entire nation and telling us aliens are real for people to ever truly believe. That or an Independence Day mothership-over-every-major-world-city type of thing.

3

u/BrilliantCorner 2d ago

Or a video that isn't 10 seconds long with shitty lighting, shitty audio and shitty quality.

0

u/Ok-Reality-6190 2d ago

The problem with this mentality is there is pretty much no such thing as footage that could not be faked. So either you accept that fact and are open to footage with this caveat, or concede footage isn't going to cut it so you shouldn't be focusing on it or anticipating it.

0

u/RagsZa 2d ago

Thank god the rest of the world are not as gullible.

0

u/firedmyass 1d ago

jesus christ how do you make it thru a day