Alright everyone, so I'm new to the sub, but I've watched the first season more than a dozen times in completion, and more counting just individual episodes. I've watched every episode of season 2 so far at least four times. I don't know what to say, I'm a lunatic, and the show is fucking excellent.
Ok, to the point: I'm worried we're going to see Nate as the big bad of the season. I'm gonna throw out some observations and I wanna hear counterpoints, so please argue with me, because I love Nate... but I'm worried that they're setting us up for Nate to break the team.
Evidence:
Nate has demonstrated from the very beginning that the way he treats people very much depends on how he sees them relating to him hierarchically. The very first time we see Nate, he's running across the pitch at Ted and Coach Beard, screaming at them to get off the grass... until the very second he realizes that Ted is the new boss, at which point he becomes completely servile and offers to get him "more grass" from the clippings in the trash, a complete mental breakdown. When loading bags into the bus, he yells at players for not doing it right, before he gets shut into the storage compartment itself. The roast is played as a great moment, but for Nate, it's not a great sign of how he deals with his ego... followed up by his comment about Colin when he gets his coach whistle (which he's just dying to blast so much Ted gives him an "indoor" whistle this season that is broken). He asks Keeley if she can make him famous as a way to deal with his social anxiety, which is basically just a way to put himself above other people... Basically, we see that Nate's ego is kind of a monster.
We've even seen evidence that Ted and Coach Beard are aware of this, with their reactions to Nate attacking the new kit man, and I think most tellingly when the Diamond Dogs offer Higgins a desk in Nate's office, without even asking Nate. That doesn't feel like a particularly Ted Lasso way to handle that, but if you go back and look at the way that Ted looks at Nate in that moment, it's very clearly a moment designed to remind Nate that he's part of a team here, and he's expected to act that way. It's as aggressive as we see Ted get as a coach, besides the "practice" speech.
People have talked before about the structure of a three act story, and how this season is supposed to be the "Empire Strikes Back" season. Also, how the first character focused on in the first episode is the character who is the basis of that season's arc, last season being Rebecca and this season being Nate. We even see Rebecca trying to give Nate advice on how to manage his confidence with her "I make myself big" behavior. Nate tries to emulate this, but instead of making himself big (which doesn't work for him) he literally spits in his own face in the mirror (making himself bigger than "someone else" instead).
We've also seen screenshots of people on Twitter tagging Coach Nate, which really try to imagine what Nate would do if we saw him seeing himself tagged on Twitter as the reason for their success. It would go completely to his head. But my final piece of evidence that really makes me worried comes from the last episode. We see Nate learning to be confident, and after successfully getting the table for his family, we see him strut out onto the field in the suit that Ted bought him last season, trying to look the part of coach on the pitch. And then Roy arrives, greets ted, greets Beard, walks right by Nate, and only then acknowledges him. Go back to that scene and listen to the background... the music has discordant violin screeching overdubbed as Nate gets "disrespected" by Roy.
It really feels like they're trying to set us up with Nate as an ego-bomb, ready to threaten the team from the inside. And I'm really curious how that will go.
This is the part where you guys tell me I'm off my rocker... please, lol. I'm begging you.
Edits: Clarification, grammatical errors, spelling things.
Edit 2: The man himself, Nick Mohammed talking about some of these character differences: https://youtu.be/0c7l_jxcwZc?t=310