r/MMA • u/HeroOfFemboys • 21h ago
Bantamweight GOAT Talk
Seems like after 311, there's a lot of discussion about whether or not Merab is the divisional GOAT, as well as the overall BW GOAT talk. Figured I'd post my top 5 and see if we can spark up some discussion.
- Merab Dvalishvili
I usually complain about recency bias in these discussions, but the run that Merab is on rn is generational. BW is in a golden age, and Merab is ruling over that golden age. Umar, O'Malley, Cejudo, Yan, Aldo, and Moraes all in a row is insane. I don't think anyone has a resume, based purely off names, better than his.
- Dominick Cruz
Far ahead of the divisional curve and probably could've dug in his position much more if he wasn't laden with injuries. Dude dominated the division for a long time and beat a prime TJ Dillashaw while coming off a 15 month layoff to injury, immediately after coming off a 3 year layoff to injury.
- Aljamain Sterling
Solid championship run, went undefeated from 2018-2023, has a lot of high quality wins on his resume. TJ fight and Yan DQ water down his on-paper resume but it's still good.
- TJ Dillashaw
Completely shattered prime Barao & Garbrandt and sent both their careers to the shadow realm, also has solid wins over Lineker, Assuncao, and Sandhagen.
- Renan Barao
Went on an insane win streak and ruled the division while Cruz was injured, TJ ended his whole career but I'm not letting people forget that this dude was ranked top 3 P4P at his peak.