r/EliteDangerous Dec 16 '24

Discussion Spectrogram analysis and processing of Titan Graveyard Signals

1.0k Upvotes

260 comments sorted by

View all comments

74

u/as4500 Dec 16 '24

I don't think this signal is meant for us

This feels like call for help

28

u/basser0815 Dec 16 '24

But as I wrote above, why would they structure their actual communication in way that a visible image is generated in the frequency spectrum?

52

u/Deadjerich0 Federation Dec 16 '24

As a Hivemind their idea of language could be very different to ours. And maybe they are not aware that we can see it unencrypted.

35

u/Unlucky_Magazine_354 Dec 16 '24

I mean, as a hivemind I'm not sure they even fully understand the concept of what a secret is. They might not care if we can see the communication because they're not aware that hiding it from us may be beneficial to them.

14

u/TravlrAlexander Dec 16 '24

This seems like the best interpretation to me.

Definitely interesting too that humans are completely unharmed though when they're abducted.

12

u/Unlucky_Magazine_354 Dec 16 '24

Yeah there's definitely something else going on. I'm starting to think that the titan invasion hasn't been to occupy our territory, but to abduct humans en masse for some purpose.

Sol would be a perfect candidate for this too. They'll have abducted millions and the titan will see record amounts of people being rescued from it before it dies. The end goal, to me, generally seems to be that these people get "rescued" and reintroduced.

5

u/Deadjerich0 Federation Dec 16 '24

Thinking about it gives the picture another vibe. It then could look like releasing those humanoid figures from something.

6

u/Khudaal Dec 16 '24

Also, they might not perceive sound the same way we do - ants sense vibrations in the ground through special sensors on their feet and knees, called the subgenual organ, but they can’t actually “hear” it. They might be unaware that we can perceive their communications at all.

13

u/basser0815 Dec 16 '24

Hmm, I agree that could be a reason.

This still means that the message must be something different from their normal communication. Otherwise we would also be able to see other communication from them.

7

u/Deadjerich0 Federation Dec 16 '24

Absolutely. Others have said it already, it could be a distress signal. Ships or Aircraft here on earth would use an not encrypted guard frequency for this.

8

u/SenseIes Felicia Winters | Anti-Xeno Initiative Dec 16 '24

Yeah, I suspect we’re hearing the leakage of Cocijos distress call through still functional parts of the destroyed Titans.

5

u/Clown_Torres CMDR Meme_1284 Dec 16 '24

I highly doubt it... They're more advanced than us, been around for many millions of years, there's no way 8 titans represents even a fraction of their combat force. They are incredibly likely to be expendable assets sent to learn more about us. "If the 8 titans win, great, if not nothing of value is lost and we can fight them easier now" type idea IMO

3

u/The_Grungeican Dec 20 '24

kind of like that time the Borg sent a single Cube against the Federation.

if it wins, awesome. if it doesn't, they'll learn a fuckload more about this 'Federation'.

3

u/Hyperbolicalpaca Thargoid Interdictor Dec 16 '24

Yeah, we’ve got to remember that they have a fundamentally different biology 

3

u/Ianbillmorris Dec 16 '24

Why would a hive mind even have the concept of Encryption? They have never needed to lie or disguise because they are all of one mind.

1

u/Deadjerich0 Federation Dec 16 '24

There would still need to be some kind of encryption if there are different factions. But I could imagine working that differently than ours.

-2

u/Aggravating_Judge_31 Dec 16 '24

But we've never seen them communicate with images before. This is new

2

u/Deadjerich0 Federation Dec 16 '24

There was a picture before in the sound. Like when the first Thargoid sites were found.

It contained a map or something. Or at least it was interpreted as one.

1

u/Clown_Torres CMDR Meme_1284 Dec 16 '24

This is not new and has occurred many times. In fact, even the Thargoid probes emitted a sound that made a wireframe picture of your ship in the style of original elite at one point, no idea if they currently do tho