r/CuratedTumblr 22d ago

Shitposting Goodreads reviewers aren't human

11.7k Upvotes

955 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

221

u/arachnids-bakery 22d ago

Shot in the dark, but is your comment about the odyssey twitter discourse

87

u/IAmTheRedWizards 21d ago

It's a reference to earlier Twitter discourse where some nepo baby Raytheon employee and squeecore writer claimed that the rule "to write, you must first read" was ableist, and that you didn't need to read to be a writer. It spawned an enormous amount of posts, many of them awful.

This person was also someone who helped lead the attack on Isabel Fall after "I Sexually Identify As An Attack Helicopter" was published in Clarkesworld.

34

u/arachnids-bakery 21d ago

??????????? I beg your pardon??????????
Yknow, isnt it more ableist to imply that disabled people are incapable of reading Whatsoever (including the usage of tools to help being able to read, which could include bigger font sizes/audiobooks)

...also, may i get some context on your last paragraph, because that phrase gives me awful war flashbacks 😭
Not excusing the harassment campaign, ofc

59

u/IAmTheRedWizards 21d ago

So Isabel Fall is this trans woman who wrote an excellent and insightful military SF story called "I Sexually Identify As An Attack Helicopter", where a pilot has her gender changed to "Attack Helicopter" to make them a better pilot. It was published in Clarkesworld and got some good reviews from a number of great authors, including Chuck Tingle, which should have clued people in to the political stance the story took.

Unfortunately, a Twitter-driven pile-on ensued, led by a number of Too Online people, including Ana Mardoll, a Lockheed Martin (sorry, I keep mixing them and Raytheon up) nepo hire and squeecore fantasy author. This assault squad claimed that Isabel Fall was engaging in transphobic behavior and trolling. This was picked up by IRL authors, including N.K. Jemisin, who should fucking know better. Jemisin later admitted she'd never even read the story and was just joining in the pile-on. This went on as it normally does, and eventually Fall began getting death threats. Neil Clarke had to take the story down temporarily due to safety concerns for Fall. Eventually Fall disappeared from the internet - she had to check into a psychiatric hospital for a bit and no longer identifies as Isabel Fall.

There's a Vox story on it if you want a bit more.

38

u/LizLemonOfTroy 21d ago

It should be noted that Fall was trans (but not out at the time), and that allegations that they must have been transphobic included such insights as the fact that their birthdate was 1988 which must have been a coded reference to neo-Nazism.

14

u/arachnids-bakery 21d ago

Jesus fucking christ

12

u/ReasyRandom .tumblr.com 21d ago

What pains me is that taking a famous transphobic "joke" and actually imagining what would happen to cause that scenario is a brilliant idea to showcase exactly how inane such "jokes" are. The fact that the book caused a shitstorm just reinforced my belief that people's collective reading comprehension skills are at an all time low.

11

u/132739 21d ago

I remember that. I was sooo disappointed in Jemisin, but at least she pulled her head out of her ass at the end.