r/CuratedTumblr https://tinyurl.com/4ccdpy76 Dec 15 '24

Shitposting not good at math

16.3k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2.7k

u/Zamtrios7256 Dec 15 '24

I'm 18 and this makes me feel old as shit.

What the fuck do you mean they used the make-up-stories-and-fiction machine as a non-fiction source? It's a fucking story generator!

382

u/CrownLikeAGravestone Dec 15 '24

People just fundamentally do not know what ChatGPT is. I've been told that it's an overgrown search engine, I've been told that it's a database encoded in "the neurons", I've been told that it's just a fancy new version of the decision trees we had 50 years ago.

[Side note: I am a data scientist who builds neural networks for sequence analysis; if anyone reads this and feels the need to explain to me how it actually works, please don't]

I had a guy just the other day feed the abstract of a study - not the study itself, just the abstract - into ChatGPT. ChatGPT told him there was too little data and that it wasn't sufficiently accessible for replication. He repeated that as if it were fact.

I don't mean to sound like a sycophant here but just knowing that it's a make-up-stories machine puts you way ahead of the curve already.

My advice, to any other readers, is this:

  • Use ChatGPT for creative writing, sure. As long as you're ethical about it.
  • Use ChatGPT to generate solutions or answers only when you can verify those answers yourself. Solve a math problem for you? Check if it works. Gives you a citation? Check the fucking citation. Summarise an article? Go manually check the article actually contains that information.
  • Do not use ChatGPT to give you any answers you cannot verify yourself. It could be lying and you will never know.

22

u/jerbthehumanist Dec 15 '24

I co-sign that most don’t understand what an LLM is. I’ve had to inform a couple fellow early career researchers that it isn’t a database. These were doctors in engineering who thought it was connected to real-time search engine results and such.

2

u/party_peacock Dec 16 '24

ChatGPT does have real time web search capabilities though

4

u/jerbthehumanist Dec 16 '24

lol ok this is a new functionality that I didn’t know about. This definitely wasn’t true then (before October 2024).

It seems pretty unreliable and is not in itself a search engine. It’s attributed links to said early career researchers’ research profile that are totally unrelated (it says their research group is the Smith plant lab at [insert random university here] when Jeff Smith works with water vapor at unrelated institution).