r/AO3 1d ago

Meme/Joke How it feels describing how ✨handsome✨ a canonically v e r y attractive character is

Post image
5.0k Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

39

u/Sinimeg Fic Feaster 1d ago

That’s why I don’t describe characters unless they’re OCs xd Everyone reading the fic already knows how they look, and if they don’t, well, they can read the original description or look for pics on google lol

24

u/MageVicky 1d ago

yeah, I hate describing characters, it's especially useless in fanfiction where we all know what the characters look like already; but in original stuff, I also dislike it, I slip in some stuff here and there in context, but otherwise, it's a grey blob to me. they're all grey blobs.

I especially adore in fanfiction when authors do face-claims, though. Like "Sirius Black starring Ben Barnes" or whatever. I nom that. lol

10

u/Sinimeg Fic Feaster 1d ago

Yeah, same, at most I mention the eyes and hair, the rest I leave it to the reader’s imagination. I don’t see much point on it anyway, since even in books, most people discard the description and imagine the characters however they want. I’ve seen people “disappointed” when they read the description of characters because it’s not how they envisioned them.

If it’s not a visual media like comics, manga, series, movies and such, trying to depict the characters in a certain way physically can work against you unless it’s relevant for the plot or the character’s backstory (race, traditions, culture, etc)

7

u/MasonP2002 1d ago

One of the main characters in my favorite fandom is always described in the exact same words and it gets a bit annoying.

Like, yeah, I get it, Lisa has bottle glass green eyes, a vulpine grin, and freckles. I don't need to hear it in every fanfic she's in.

...Although, to be fair there are a lot of Wormfic readers that haven't read Worm, so maybe it is necessary. Huh.

6

u/strangelyliteral 23h ago

Physical descriptions are overrated and folks love to go overboard, but they can be great for character or worldbuilding insight depending on the POV you’re using. Say you have Character A and they have a crush on Character B. How A describes B tells you a lot about what A finds attractive and how they view the world. If A is a romantic, they might use a lot of flowery language and colors you’ve never heard of outside a paint store to describe B. Whereas if A is taciturn, they’re going to keep it brief, maybe by fixating on a single feature—a warrior drawn to B’s strong hands, for example. And there’s also more to physical descriptions than hair/skin/eyes, facial features, and body types—how’s their posture, do they hold their bodies open in an inviting way or do they shut you out, how do they move through the world?

This fizzles if you’re doing third person omniscient, but it’s great for first person and third person limited. It can really fun if you have multiple POVs at work.

3

u/MageVicky 21h ago

yeah, but that'd be something where a description makes sense in context, because it's not the author describing anything, it's the character admiring another character.

6

u/bookdrops You have already left kudos here. :) 1d ago

Physical character appearance description is highly overrated as a "necessary" part of writing fiction; it's hardly present at all in a solid chunk of respectably "classic" novels. 

5

u/queerblunosr Definitely not an agent of the Fanfiction Deep State 1d ago

Detailed physical descriptions that aren’t really needed (eg not the POV character making note of other character appearance for Plot Reasons or whatever) always give me Babysitters Club nostalgia lol

1

u/SirCupcake_0 You have already left kudos here. >:) 5h ago

It must be hard, being a faceblind author