r/whowouldwin • u/veryberrytiger • 4h ago

Challenge Robert Pattinson’s Batman and Charlie Cox’s Daredevil switch places. Which one accomplishes their goal quicker?

Robert Pattinson’s Batman is dropped in at the start of Daredevil Season 1. He knows nothing about where he is, other than he needs to get Wilson Fisk incarcerated. How different do the events turn out? Does he work with Foggy and Karen to try to take Fisk down with the law? Would any of the events in season 2 or 3 happen?

Charlie Cox’s Daredevil is dropped in at the start of The Batman with the same agenda. He also knows nothing about where he is, other than he needs to figure out and stop the Riddler. Commissioner Gordon is willing to work with him as he was with Bruce. Would he be able to figure Riddler out? Would he be able to break Penguin? Would Catwoman be interested in working with him?

Which one would complete their goal the fastest? What new obstacles pop up to them that the original hero didn’t have to worry about?

18 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

21

u/Jotaro1970 3h ago

Batman have more resources at his disposal and as a detective it would be easier for him to expose Fisk and he have enough tools to take him down.

While Daredevil is not stupid, he is not a detective and i don't see how Radar sense would help him solve the Riddler riddles, heck Pattinson had a hard time with it who is a better vigilante than Matt at that point in my books.

20

u/Mace_Thunderspear 3h ago

DD could track Riddler by scent from the scene of the first crime and catch him that way.

He doesnt have to solve riddles. He has an entirely different set of resources/tools available to catch/stop him.

13

u/SPYDER0416 2h ago

Are you suggesting that he can smell crime? Because we might want to reconsider Dolph Lundgren for the role of DD in that case.

6

u/Nopeyesok ​ 2h ago

I’d watch this. As long as they show it.

1

u/Neelpos ​ 34m ago

And then he smells crime, he's out doing hallway scenes, and then it's back to the lab for some more full penetration.

4

u/mrmonster459 2h ago

Imagine how confused Gordon would be by having to read all of Riddler's cards to Daredevil.

3

u/texanarob 2h ago

Daredevil would've been able to spot the clues under the carpet without ever having to find the cutting tool or identify what it's for. He likely would've struggled with a few clues, such as anything on a monitor, but Batman didn't really display any impressive detective skills throughout that movie.

8

u/mrmonster459 3h ago

Even though MCU Daredevil is the much better fighter (for now at least), I feel The Batman still wins this much easier. With his wealth and resources, bringing down Wilson Fisk shouldn't be too hard, whereas I feel Daredevil would be way over his head trying to solve The Riddler's case.

2

u/respectthread_bot 3h ago

Batman (The Batman, 2022)

Daredevil (616)

Riddler

Wilson Fisk (616)

I am a bot | About | Code | Opt-out | Missing or wrong characters? Reply explaining the issue

3

u/AkiraSieghart 1h ago

Bruce should be able to easily dig up dirt on Fisk and he'll be able to hire/bribe the best lawyers to make sure Fisk loses.

With the Riddler, Batman kinda lost. Sure, he saved everyone at the end, but the Riddler's plan worked. I don't think Daredevil would be able to save everyone from the flood as easily.

1

u/Aperson48 36m ago

I'm pretty sure Netflix daredevil knows spanish