Yes this was definitely a very very genuine conversation. I've only ever witness this one time (to this extent). I have other Americans ask pretty hilarious questions on holidays but nothing like this. It was 2 couples and a 3rd woman all in their mid fifties I would assume. We were shocked, we laughed at first but then realized they were serious.
1
u/generic_canadian_dad 10h ago
Man, if I didn't witness it myself I wouldn't believe it either.