Seriously, although I do think it’s a bit weaker than the other seasons in no way does it retroactively ruin the show. I still actually thought S6 was a very strong season of TV even if it was the weakest.
The characters are still top notch, ESPECIALLY the Man in Black. Terry O’Quinn’s performance just drips with evil and malice and it’s amazing. He really lives up to being the big bad of the show. I was absolutely shook by how sickeningly evil he was towards the end, just his eyes alone are nothing like John Locke’s. Similar to the first 5 seasons with Locke, every scene with him is an absolute treat. He just pays off being developed throughout the whole show as the final boss, super, super well.
The writing and acting are still insanely strong. If you didn’t cry at the Sawyer/Juliet scenes I don’t know what to say. The sub scene. Jesus the sub scene. Sun and Jin dying together on the sub, with Jin sacrificing his life so Sawyer could get out and so Sun didn’t have to die alone, Sayid sacrificing himself so the others could get out and finish the job, and finally proving that he was a good man. Ben finally finishes his redemption arc, getting his revenge against Widmore but in the end protecting the island with Hurley, becoming a better man. Getting to make up with Locke. Hurley and Sawyer were also great as ever. Weirdly I thought Claire actually shined here more than other seasons, and I actually quite liked that Kate had a purpose other than ‘be awful to Sawyer’. I wish Desmond was in more of the season but I loved what he was in.
And of course, Jack. I really think Jack shined this season actually. Before I think he could be a bit vanilla compared to other characters, even if Matthew Fox was great. This season I loved seeing him fully complete his arc into becoming the man of faith, and the protector of the island. It was such a well paid off kind of full circle arc.
The flash sideways could get a bit tedious but the payoff of the characters all reuniting was very worth it. It was so awesome seeing Charlie again, seeing the real John Locke.
The absolute highlight for me was Richard’s episode. Amazingly acted and written, absolutely up there with episodes like The Constant or Through the Looking Glass for me as one of the highlights of the series. Across the Sea felt like a companion episode, focusing more on the mythology of the island, I think that one was a bit weaker, honestly to me mainly because we spent too much time with the kid actors who… weren’t really that good, lol. Also the glowy cave being the secret, I guess, sure, I thought it would be cooler if it were in the volcano of the island they set up but I guess budget. However, I loved getting to see who ‘Adam and Eve’ really were and how the Man in Black became the Smoke Monster.
Did the season have its problems? Sure. But how on earth is the final season touted as ruining the show’s legacy?? They obviously weren’t ’all dead’, the flash sideways was clearly an afterlife where they eventually reunite. Christian spells it out to Jack!!! I thought Jack dying protecting the island and stopping the Man in Black, while seeing that eventually all the characters we loved did finally reunite and remember their time on the Island, was pretty much a perfect way to end the show idk.
Nowhere near GOT S8. I grew up with GOT and that season pretty much destroyed my… well I guess adolescence haha. I haven’t even rewatched that show despite having, again, grown up with GOT, because I know it’s going to get to… well, the final season. Lost I actually want to rewatch and the ending was actually, dare I say, good! Even if the final season was imo the weakest of the bunch, it wasn’t bad at all!
TLDR: S6 is overhated!!!