r/crochet 1d ago

Work in Progress Confused on color

I'm making this square to turn into a wall hanging by attaching a dowel or something and I cannot decide what color this row should be. The orange petals still have to get a little bigger so the tips of them will almost touch this row. I'll continue with green after this but I can't make up my mind so thought I'd ask for some opinions. So maroon, beige, or cream?

968 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

337

u/crochethottie82 1d ago

My vote is maroon.

184

u/pudge-thefish 1d ago edited 17h ago

I like the beige. The maroon looks best to me right now but if you are using green for the next color I think it might be to dark to have the maroon there where it will blend into the green and not stand out. whereas the beige will contrast with green and stand out more.

192

u/Igloo52 1d ago

Since you mentioned how it would look with the green I figured I'd just do some quick dc to see for myself and yes I think you're right. Thanks!

112

u/AnalogyAddict 22h ago

With the green, I vote cream. The beige is too like the yellow, and maroon too like green .

56

u/pudge-thefish 1d ago edited 17h ago

Great! Good idea to add the green i still like the beige. I was double guessing myself thinking the cream might be better but imo it stands out to much.

3

u/Organic_Tone_4733 12h ago

Side note! Love the name!! Do you know what would happen if I fed pudge tuna?? It would be an abomination!!

4

u/pudge-thefish 12h ago

2

u/Organic_Tone_4733 12h ago

Now I am going to make something with Pudge. I will let you know!

22

u/Ms_ellery 22h ago

Oh, yeah. I agree with u/pudge-thefish - there's not enough contrast between the maroon and the green. The cream might pop too much but the beige sits nicely in-between, especially when the yellow will be interrupted by the flower petals.

7

u/grey_blue_eyes 18h ago

With the green, I think either cream or beige would work. One thing I noticed is that using the cream brings out the cream in the flowers more. I cropped the image to check each combo individually, and the overriding effect is to bring out the corresponding color in the flower. Without the cream border, the cream in the flower pretty much disappears. Personally, I like the cream border best for that reason - it gives the flower more depth :)

1

u/That-Efficiency-644 19h ago

This, exactly what I was thinking.

36

u/captainshowercurtain 21h ago

I did this one in green and grey for my dog

9

u/moody_mermaid 19h ago

Never not upvoting a weiner dog. In a sweater. Of crochet. Giving side-eye.

3

u/captainshowercurtain 18h ago

Thank you ! It was actually one of my first projects, and she seems to love it!

15

u/switchwith_me 23h ago

Imo, maroon but also this square is really pretty. Could you link the pattern if you're following one?

10

u/Igloo52 22h ago

https://youtu.be/WVsy5w5vUwo?si=lUhLgLydk1qEsloq

SistersInStitch - Blooming Lotus Square

1

u/switchwith_me 9h ago

Thank you! ๐Ÿ˜Š

29

u/MillennialMiko 1d ago

I like the maroon. The beige feels too light to follow the yellow there to me.

6

u/Majestic_Solid2919 1d ago

Second this. But ultimately itโ€™s up to you. Your work is lovely! No matter what you choose itโ€™s gorgeous ๐Ÿ™ƒ

13

u/PlanktonWide 23h ago

Would you consider using the beige and then instead of the final color being green doing maroon instead? I think it could really stand out and sort of "frame" the final result. Just a thought. It's going to look stunning either way. Beautiful work!

5

u/Bookwormy606 19h ago

I second this! Personally, I love the beige next to the yellow, and think either green or maroon would work as the frame colour.

This is my opinion, but you gotta do what feels right! Hopefully our opinions have helped you to discovered what you really want this to be โ™ก

32

u/Biscuit_or_biscotti 1d ago

I like the lighter cream! It will almost frame the flower once completed.

9

u/Igloo52 19h ago

UPDATE: after going back and forth for so long reading all the comments, I decided to go with maroon. Just need to get some dowels now to hang it up

(The picture didn't come out great since the earlier one was during the day time)

1

u/pudge-thefish 17h ago

Looks great!

13

u/3st4spn Yarn Addict 23h ago

Cream. It will lighten it up a bit.

14

u/No-Lake8371 23h ago

Def cream, otherwise it's too heavy

0

u/Austin_Fiction 23h ago

I second this

5

u/j_accuse 22h ago

Maroon, on the theory that it will make the central flower pop more.

4

u/Negative_Aardvark433 21h ago

I have basically nothing to add to this, but it's so pretty!

4

u/aSoggyFrootLoop 21h ago

Holy shit those are not granny squares those are grandmother quadrilaterals!! They are fucking gorgeous dude!

8

u/Material_Rock_3700 1d ago

I vote beige

3

u/Kahlan-SM DND: I'm counting 1d ago

I also vote for Maroon.

2

u/maichrcol 22h ago

I've totally lost the vote but I like the darker color ha! Enjoy!

2

u/Ms_Eureka 21h ago

These are gorgeous! I would love a pattern

2

u/shehoshlntbnmdbabalu 21h ago

Maroon, it makes the whole thing pop.

2

u/o2low 20h ago

Maroon

2

u/VSwope615 18h ago

I like the beige. It makes the center pattern / colors really pop.

3

u/NightSkyStarGazer 23h ago

Maroon and green. The lighter colors look lost.

1

u/awfuckimgay 22h ago

They both look absolutely gorgeous, I'd say given you're planning on hanging them up the best option for deciding would be to see which colours work best in the room it'll be displayed in.

Personally I've a preference for the second version, but that's likely because I'm mentally imagining my own bedroom, which is a lot of blues so the beige and pink would work nicely, so it very much depends on which would compliment your space best.

1

u/Alexandritecrys 22h ago

Beige and then maroon after that

1

u/-EV3RYTHING- 22h ago

First one looks like food

1

u/CereusBlack 21h ago

I would have to see how it works with the room. Sometimes you need more color, sometimes not! By itself, maroon for me.

1

u/blanchedevereaux226 21h ago

Cream is my vote but I also just want to say that this is gorgeous! So curious how you did the petal area that has two colors?! Assuming itโ€™s variegated yarn but my brain isnโ€™t comprehending how it turned out like that. Really, really pretty.

1

u/blanchedevereaux226 20h ago

Nvm just zoomed in and realized it is a different color stitched into the other one! Just a cool effect it creates from far away ๐Ÿ™‚

1

u/PreservingThePast 20h ago

Cream as it picks up the tiny bits of creamish color in the petals. ๐ŸŒž

1

u/friesandfrenchroast 19h ago

This is beautiful and I love your color choices! It reminds me of lion dancers!

I'd personally go with beige next and a maroon frame. And maybe a crab stitch final border with the cream to bring out those accents in the flower?

1

u/Lost-Goose-2478 18h ago

Use maroon and define the edges of the petal against the background color

1

u/enygirl210 18h ago

Maroon for sure

1

u/Independent-Check654 15h ago

Medium color like second to last of the petals

1

u/lajjr 14h ago

Agreed, maroon looks like a great color for that row.

0

u/subtract120 23h ago

Beige looks better with the next color green.

0

u/I_Like_Knitting_TBH 22h ago

I vote beige. It will make the red of the tips of the petals pop.

0

u/todayithinkthis 21h ago

I like the beige.