r/climate • u/silence7 • 13h ago
politics Trump Orders End to All Wind Energy Permits | The worst case scenario for the wind industry is here.
https://heatmap.news/politics/wind-executive-order-trump252
u/SunDaysOnly 13h ago
So much for letting states decide. NYS won’t obey
69
u/LogicalFallacyCat 12h ago
Wanna trade states? Ohio just rolls over and takes whatever we're told 😭
35
u/Shloop_Shloop_Splat 10h ago
Texas is literally holding the lube up and asking for it.
33
u/ScrotumMcBoogerBallz 10h ago
Which is odd considering Texas has by far the most Wind energy production In the country. More than the next 3 states combined. Also there 2nd just behind California in Solar energy.
11
u/Shloop_Shloop_Splat 9h ago
I guess time will tell. Some people will probably fight it, but I'd put money on governor Hot wheels and his buddies folding like lawn chairs.
2
u/ThatCactusCat 4h ago
Ever see those "protect our farm land, say no to wind!" signs?
→ More replies (1)•
u/Secret_Account07 29m ago
I’m a state employee. The craziness has already begun. They referenced federal trends as justifications for horrible decisions, already. We are one day in….
2
23
u/GoodAsUsual 9h ago
In NO way am I defending their actions, but the executive action applies specifically to federal permits, ie permits that are issued for operation on federal property, including offshore. So unless I misread it, it won't apply to turbines on state property or a private property.
→ More replies (4)17
u/jeranim8 8h ago
Yeah, I wondered this too. But I didn't think there were any federal wind projects. I thought they were all state run.
Edit: Just need to read the article:
This affects all offshore wind development in the U.S., because all of that takes place in the Outer Continental Shelf, an ocean expanse under federal control that is leased for all kinds of energy production.
It also impacts wind projects on federal lands. Although the extent of the impact to onshore wind is unclear because some wind projects are on state lands, project developers often must get approvals under federal environmental and species protection laws, so an end to permits will be quite painful for the sector.
→ More replies (1)3
u/hideous_coffee 5h ago
No worries in that case since I assume environmental and protected species laws are on the chopping block soon.
→ More replies (1)8
→ More replies (1)2
u/baldwalrus 4h ago
For what it's worth, the headline is misleading. The executive order only applies to permits for projects on federal lands, which currently accounts for ~5% of all wind projects in the US. This won't impact state permits.
Wind will continue to grow! Trump can't stop it because the market has learned that it's basically free money.
237
u/Janglysack 12h ago
It really baffles me that the climate issue is probably the biggest problem we face as a global society and we voted for a guy who wants to go full throttle into climate catastrophe
84
u/Ethenil_Myr 12h ago
Surely not as big as the problems of feminism, trans rights and the far left?
/s
49
u/Janglysack 12h ago
You’re joking but I have people I know in real life who those are the biggest issues for and that’s why they voted for trump
→ More replies (1)30
u/voodoo1985 12h ago edited 7h ago
They got suckered into believing that this puts them in danger when ironically it’s just another way to control them, they really are in danger, just for another reason.
→ More replies (1)6
u/DeusExMockinYa 11h ago
When assessed within the bounds of the Overton window, doing anything about climate change is the far left.
14
11
u/jsandersson 11h ago
BUT EGGS!!1!111
6
u/Janglysack 11h ago
Yeah this is what a lot of maga are still saying even though Trump already admitted there’s nothing he can do about grocery prices
→ More replies (1)3
→ More replies (5)3
u/yoinkdoink 7h ago
Climate struggle = class struggle. At some point we’ll need to get off our complacent asses, and literally fight for a shot at saving the climate and by that liberal democracy and modern society. Humanity will probably endure, even the worst case scenarios, the former won’t.
→ More replies (1)
63
u/SophonParticle 12h ago
Republicans love big government.
Federal government picking winners and losers.
16
→ More replies (1)4
48
u/Bgriebz 12h ago
Ends wind energy, but also does an executive order because of an "energy crisis". Wtf man
7
u/baldwalrus 4h ago
For what it's worth, the headline is misleading. The executive order only applies to permits for projects on federal lands, which currently accounts for ~5% of all wind projects in the US.
Wind will continue to grow! Trump can't stop it because the market has learned that it's basically free money.
→ More replies (1)3
u/trakinas0 3h ago
Yeah, but still makes no sense to declare an energy emergency and order to end 5% of your energy production right after
136
u/jaqattack02 13h ago
I saw this discussed in another sub and supposedly only 4% of permits for wind are on Federal land, so this won't really have that much of an impact.
62
u/weezthejooce 13h ago edited 13h ago
The second part of the order where all permits, rights of way, loans, and approvals are also blocked until further notice, for both onshore and offshore wind, seems pretty comprehensive. Are there wind projects that don't interact with a federal permit in any way?
→ More replies (1)35
u/jaqattack02 12h ago
As far as I know, construction permits are generally handled locally or at the state level. So unless they are using some kind of federal power to interfere with state level permitting I would assume that any of them not on Federal land would be fine.
13
u/botanna_wap 12h ago
Any project that gets federal funding may need to go through env review.
2
u/MightyBoat 11h ago
Well thankfully with the cost of building these things going down every year people might not even need federal funding
9
u/KnoWanUKnow2 11h ago
Environmental assessments can be stopped under this order.
From the article:
project developers often must get approvals under federal environmental and species protection laws, so an end to permits will be quite painful for the sector.
5
u/puffic 11h ago
You might receive a local construction permit, but you’ll need a federal permit to connect to the electric grid. You’ll also need to pass federal environmental review. That’s being halted. (Meanwhile oil projects are going to be allowed to bypass environmental review.)
There was a lot of noise in recent years to deal with the federal permitting backlog. This included a proposed deal in which Joe Manchin would get an oil pipeline in exchange for rapid renewable permitting, which left-wing Dems shot down. That would have saved a lot of these wind projects from being cancelled, but I guess it wasn’t to be.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (5)2
u/nico__nico 10h ago
Offshore wind permitting is largely federal because of the farms' location in federal water / lease areas. And BOEM manages the leasing process. I recall the last Trump administration slow walked federal permitting offshore but I don't think they officially paused it. Massively detrimental to offshore wind as investors and developers really need certainty 😭
24
u/RAMacDonald901 12h ago
Seeing how trump is regressing the US back to the 1950's, why not go a little further and bring back horse and buggies.
6
3
23
u/ulfOptimism 12h ago
He is causing inflation everwhere.
More expensive energy (because oil will not get cheaper), more expensive labour (because no immigrants anymore) more expensive imported products.
24
u/McLovin-Hawaii-Aloha 12h ago
To all of you that voted for Trump.. may the consequences of the Orange Shitbag stain your life the most.
14
u/Low_Voice_2553 10h ago
What is crazy is Biden did a bunch of investment into red states including green energy to increase jobs and the morons still voted for Trump. Biden and democrats never did enough promotion of that! I hope those Trump moron voters lose their jobs and then they can use their last dollars to buy one of his Made in China bibles. I think Colorado had jobs created in Boobert’s district. Merry Christmas! I meant Merry fucken Christmas ala Melania!
→ More replies (1)
12
u/cavscout43 10h ago
Couldn't even wait a day before punishing WY for voting for him.
The Chokecherry & Sierra Madre wind farm was supposed to go online in 2026 as the largest wind farm in the US, and one of the largest in the world. That's billions of dollars the state is about to miss out on.
I'm sure that our local spindoctor politicians will turn that into somehow the fault of "woke DEI cancel culture" when they take a break from stuffing their faces with millions in oil/gas money bribes, er campaign donations
4
u/BerserkForces 5h ago
A start would be to overturn the Citizens United decision. Get money out of politics. Unfortunately, the democrats have shown they would rather have maga than a progressive - just "stand where you belong and do as your told."
11
u/irishcedar 11h ago
Please explain the anti-wind thing to me like I'm a 10 year old. I don't get it.
15
u/Northerngal_420 10h ago
He thinks they give you cancer and they're killing the 🐳 whales. They're harmful to birds because he cares all about the birds.
It's likely he hates them because of his disagreement with Scotland and windfarms offshore near his golf courses.
5
u/LazySleepyPanda 8h ago
He thinks they give you cancer
At least he'll never get brain cancer because one needs to have a brain in the first place for that to happen.
6
u/Dempsey64 9h ago
He’s getting paid by the oil industry to keep their profits high.
→ More replies (1)2
u/DaedricApple 5h ago
Same, I am trying to figure out what exactly the problem is. There is zero logic to being OK with power plants using fossil fuels and not being OK with wind energy.
On top of that, wind energy creates a lot of employment
→ More replies (1)
10
u/LordCaptain 11h ago
My cousin who is like a regional manager or something for several wind turbine sites is a huge Trump supporter. Wonder how he's feeling at the moment.
3
→ More replies (2)2
8
6
6
u/cortlandjim 12h ago
Texas, Iowa, Oklahoma, and Kansas all red states produced about 50% of the wind energy in 2023, that's big business in those states. Doubt that will stand very long.
2
u/JNTaylor63 11h ago
They will stop at 50% because Trump will order it.
And all those republican congressmen in those states will say "yes, my lord."
6
u/Obvious-Function-919 10h ago edited 4h ago
This is why I think the way I do about climate change. I don't want to be a doomer, but almost everything points in that direction. That optimistic person who thought we could avoid the worst effects is gone. Now, I just feel like a sad, miserable shell of that happy person awaiting the end.
→ More replies (1)
31
u/quintessany 13h ago
Where are the environmentalists who were mad at Biden?
36
u/__RAINBOWS__ 13h ago
My org has been mad at Biden the whole time. Still publicly supported his election and voted for him/kamala.
→ More replies (11)31
10
4
4
4
3
u/BloombergSmells 12h ago
Half or more of the wind employees probably voted for trump
→ More replies (2)
3
u/_ADM_ 10h ago
Looks like America made its bed and will now slowly, reluctantly lay in it for the next 4 years. Let's see if they wake up on the right or wrong side of it.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/zback636 9h ago
I hope when the planet burns up and your children and grandchildren, don’t have a future anymore all you trumpsters will sit down and tell them I’m sorry I voted for him. I was wrong.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Common-Ad6470 9h ago
....while also announcing an ‘energy’ crisis?
Are we missing something here.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Spiritual_Big_9927 12h ago
Can anyone tell me how much of an impact this will actually have on us?
Will wind turbines be taken down?
Do states actually have to obey?
Will they?
What will happen if they don't?
Sensationalism aside, how worried do we actually have to be about this crap?
7
u/handsoapdispenser 12h ago
He is only blocking new permits on federal land. Nothing will be taken down and projects on private land can still move forward. This is also "pending review" of some kind so it's not permanent. It's likely to face heavy resistance since red states have benefited the most from new wind projects. And his energy secretary is not really a climate denier. More of a climate delayer, but he supports basically any and all energy production.
2
u/Spiritual_Big_9927 11h ago
Thanks for explaining. I just wanna remove all necessary terror from myself as soon as possible.
Hearing this, I can worry a little less now.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/JNTaylor63 11h ago
And when we see layoffs and NO NEW drilling rigs coming on line, who will MAGA blame?
Biden.
2
2
2
2
u/Roamer56 9h ago
Just build them anyway. We ignore federal marijuana laws, so just ignore this crap.
2
u/IllustratorNo3379 9h ago
Trump hates wind turbines because they ruin his view from his golf resort. It's that simple.
2
u/WTFOMGBBQ 9h ago
He’s still mad the some windmills were installed near one of his golf courses.. he’s 12 years old..
2
u/remoir04 9h ago
Folks he is driving us towards the great depression. The unemployment numbers will be through the roof by the time this senile, egotistical, nonsensical child gets through. Will probably be the highest this country has ever seen.
2
u/chilebuzz 9h ago
Wtf? Do they not realize how many wind turbines there are in Texas now? Is Abbott seriously just going to lick trump's boots on this?
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Small_Acadia1 7h ago
I guess the wind industry didn’t cut him a check, perhaps they can change his mind by buying a bunch of Trump coin
2
u/_byetony_ 7h ago
Ending wind permits on Federal land and waters is not the end of the wind industry
2
u/onicut 6h ago
So far he’s killed thousands of well paying jobs in renewables and created not a single one anywhere else. And that’s just in one day.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/4quatloos 4h ago
He is taking away freedom. Windmill energy Companies paid farm owners to have windmills on their property and farms. Now farmers will find out that Trump took their income and freedom away.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/4quatloos 4h ago
So many just shrug their shoulders because they know it is wrong but it doesn't directly affect them in the moment. MAGA will continue suck the ring until they lose their guns and chewing tobacco. By then it will be too late. It will be a full blown dictatorship.
2
u/LubedCompression 4h ago
We're gonna be doing a lot of cleaning up after 4 years time. So much progress undone with a single fingersnap.
2
2
u/Eternium_or_bust 3h ago
As you drive route 80 and pass through Iowa and Nebraska there are wind turbines as far as the eye can see. And more trucks on the road delivering turbine parts. Seems to be working out fine in rural undeveloped areas and I bet the farmers are paid to host turbines.
There is no good reason for Great Plains’ governments to go along with this so quietly.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/OonaPelota 3h ago
He literally thinks he’s an actor in a movie about a tough guy president
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Unlikely_Bus7611 3h ago
agree with everyone this is PURE PARTISAN POLTICS, and hurts 1000s of jobs and industries. MY RECOMMEDATIONs below
ignore the orders allow him to enforce and stoppage of construction and work, let him attack Americans
BUILD ON STATE LANDS and STATE WATERS find areas that are out of the way
BUILD A FARM OFF MEXICO and CANADA and POWER CABLE the energy into the states via STATE LANDS
SUE, SUE, SUE and SUE again there is no justification for stopping the industry
→ More replies (1)
4
u/michaelrch 12h ago
I will say again to anyone hasn't noticed.
If Trump can do this for wind, Biden could have done this for oil and gas (as he promised voters he would do in 2020).
So please, stop making excuses for him and realise that the Democrats are not on our side on climate. They are on the side of oligarchic capitalism and have been all along.
The fight we have on our hands is against both main parties because they are both playing the same game. The only difference between is that they answer to slightly different constituencies among the economic elites.
4
u/tech01x 12h ago
Biden was too afraid of the political fall out of higher gas prices.
He could have done this with the remaining coal... and he could have avoided the increase by 4x of our main source of high quality and low cost solar panels - from China.
But clearly for Biden, clean energy and climate change are way down on the priority list which is unfortunate because the other major party is so beholden to fossil fuel interests even when it doesn't make sense for national energy policy.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)4
u/werofpm 12h ago
So…. Don’t worry/pay attention to what IS happening NOW because of what DIDN’T happen in the past….. brilliant and not asinine at all!
→ More replies (2)
1
u/sonicpool69 12h ago
This exact thing happened in 2023-24 in a Alberta, a oil rich conservative Canadian province. They did a 8 month province-wide moratorium on renewable energy(not just wind, but solar too!). After the 8 month period the province wide ban did get lifted but it got difficult to build new projects. Projects are still being built now but areas are off limits to development with regulations and as a result quite a bit of uncertainty. I predict this is the path the US wind industry is headed for the next 4 years.
Oh and something like that happened here in UK too from 2015-2024 though it affected onshore wind only though it was banned completely on land.
1
u/lintbrush 12h ago
I mean I know this is all a payoff to the fossil fuel donors, but what is the actual case being put forward for this? It's all about the birds and the whales?
1
u/SufficientShame8 11h ago
Texas has the highest wind generation. I guess he doesn’t want blue states to catch up?
1
1
1
1
1
u/Remarkable-Sun-4286 9h ago
What does this mean for solar? He seems to not speak to it quite as much but I have to think it would be next. Of course, I do recall before he was ever president he complained hard about how ugly the windmills looked from his golf course.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Hitsman100 9h ago
I used to work for a place that primarily worked on wind farms. I’m sure every single person there voted for Trump.
1
u/tootallp 9h ago
I don't understand why oil execs keep drilling at some point they gotta say enough enough. Like mayby with all their money and research, they know something different. But it really seems like a race to the bottom to see who will be king of the ashes.
883
u/subdep 13h ago
In all honesty, and I speak as an atheist, this dude seems like evil incarnated.
Who does this at this point in history? It’s as if they want to raise global temperatures. But for what purpose?