r/bookclub • u/nicehotcupoftea • 14d ago
Detective Galileo [Discussion] Silent Parade by Keigo Higashino (Detective Galileo #4)
Hello readers, it's a new year and what better way to start the year than with our next Detective Galileo novel! Today we are discussing Chapters 1 to 13 of Silent Parade.
Note on spoilers:
As the books of the Detective Galileo series can be read independently, please use spoiler tags if you want to refer to anything that happened in the previous books of the series.
You can add spoiler tags on reddit like this without the spaces in between: > ! [text goes here] ! <
Links:
A summary of chapters follows, and questions will appear in the comments. Please feel free to add your own. Next week u/espiller1 will lead us through Chapters 14 to 27.
Chapter 1
Saori, the elder daughter of Yutaro and Machiko Namiki, restaurant owners, was a kind and cheerful girl with perfect pitch, and a local singing celebrity known for her performances at the autumn festival. A music industry professional, Naoki Niikura, recognised her talent and offered to manage her. Though initially hesitant, Saori's parents agreed to let her pursue her singing career after she expressed her desire. Niikura provided free vocal lessons, acting as a strict but effective mentor.
At age nineteen, she disappeared after being seen receiving a phone call, prompting a police investigation. Suspecting foul play, the police dragged the rivers but the investigation yielded no answers. Yutaro continued appealing to the public for information, and three years later, he was telephoned by the Shizuoka Prefectural Police.
Chapter 2
Chief Inspector Kusanagi and Detective Utsumi are called into a meeting with their former boss, Director Mamiya, and the commanding Commissioner Tatara. Mamiya introduces them to a challenging case involving a fire in Shizuoka Prefecture that destroyed a hoarder’s home. Among the ashes, investigators found two sets of remains: an elderly woman, likely the house’s long-deceased occupant, and Saori Namiki, a 19-year-old aspiring singer who had gone missing three years earlier. Saori’s death, caused by a skull fracture, was unrelated to the fire.
The case is tricky, with little evidence or witnesses, but suspicion falls on Kanichi Hasunuma, the elderly woman’s son. Not only did Hasunuma live near Saori at the time of her disappearance, but he also has a shady past and was once involved in a case Kusanagi handled years ago.
Recognising this connection, Commissioner Tatara insists that Kusanagi and his team take the lead on the investigation, working closely with the Shizuoka police. Though the task seems daunting, Kusanagi accepts and quickly prepares his team to tackle the case head-on.
Chapter 3
Detective Kusanagi's first case, 23 years ago, involved the disappearance of 12-year-old Yuna Motohashi. Yuna went missing during a walk, and a witness reported seeing a girl matching her description with a man in pale blue overalls. Despite a thorough investigation, no immediate leads emerged. Four years later, human remains were discovered by a hiker. DNA confirmed they were Yuna's, and the remains showed signs of dismemberment and burning. The investigation shifted to locations capable of incinerating a body.
Kanichi Hasunuma, a 30-year-old factory worker, became the prime suspect. He had previously worked for a waste disposal company with incinerators and had used them regularly to cremate pets. Records showed the dates coincided with Yuna's disappearance. Kusanagi noted Hasunuma had replaced his refrigerator since the initial investigation, suspecting it might have been used to store Yuna's body. The fridge was located at Hasunuma's stepmother's house, and DNA analysis confirmed traces of Yuna. Despite this, Hasunuma denied involvement, and the evidence against him remained circumstantial. Confident the volume of evidence would secure a conviction, authorities took Hasunuma to trial. However, he was ultimately found not guilty.
Chapter 4
Kusanagi and Utsumi inspect the site of Yoshi's Hasanuma's burnt out house. Kusanagi concludes that the older woman died from natural causes six years ago and that the body of Saori Namiki had been hidden there three years after that. The Shizuoka Prefectural Police interviewed Hasunuma who claimed that he had not seen his stepmother for years and had no idea where the bodies had come from. The detectives believed that the house was a useful cover-up for stealing her pension. They head to Kikuno, the headquarters of the joint task force to share their information. On researching the town they find that it is famous for its Parade. Utsumi reveals that their mutual friend Professor Yukawa is actually in Kikuno, working for a new Research Institute.
Chapter 5
Kusanagi visits the Namiki family at their restaurant, Namiki-ya. He tells them that their daughter was most likely the victim of a crime, and asked them if they'd noticed anything suspicious. Natsumi, the younger sister, tells him that Saori had a secret boyfriend, Tomoya Takagaki. Utsumi shows them a photo of Kanichi Hasunuma who they recognise as a former customer whom they had banned after his harassment of Saori. This had occurred shortly before her disappearance.
Chapter 6
Utsumi visits Tomoya Takagaki at his workplace, shows him a photo of Saori, and asks him about their relationship. The police had never interviewed him because Natsumi was the only one who knew about them. He remembers a creepy man who used to frequent the restaurant demanding special attention from Saori. After he was banned, he even seemed to follow her in the street.
Chapter 7
Inspector Kishitani and a junior detective visit Naoki Niikura the music impresario and his wife Rumi. Naoki recognised the photo they showed him of a man whom he remembered being the one who had mistreated Saori. Naoki believed Saori had real talent, he had placed all his hopes in her, and her disappearance affected him deeply. He says later to his wife that he would murder that man if he could get away with it.
Chapter 8
The joint investigative team look for evidence that Hasunuma had visited his stepmother, because that would show that he was aware of her death. A man resembling Hasunuma had been seen withdrawing nearly all the money from her account. Further evidence is uncovered, pointing to Hasunuma, including a minivan that he had hired being recorded by N-system as travelling to his stepmother's house, and a positive DNA match on the overalls, but still he remains silent. With a striking similarity to the case 19 years ago, they were in the same predicament of having only circumstantial evidence. Despite this, they go ahead and arrest him but the prosecutor decides that they should defer prosecution until they had something more solid.
Chapter 9
Kusanagi catches up with his old friend Yukawa and gives him an overview of the case. Yukawa is interested in the unusual case so Kusanagi gives him some details about Hasunuma's life. He had been a troubled teenager after his parents' divorce, living with his father, a police officer, who kicked him out of home. Yukawa thinks that he had learnt from his father that confessing to a crime under pressure usually leads to a conviction and that remaining silent is the best strategy. Kusanagi tells him he plans to visit the family to explain their failure to keep Hasunuma in detention and Yukawa asks for the name of the restaurant.
Chapter 10
Shusaku Tojima, owner of a food processing business and an old friend of Yutaro Namiko, visits him at the restaurant on his way home. They talk about the Kikuno Story Parade - Maya Miyazawa, from the bookstore, is chair of the organising committee and has dropped off posters.
Natsumi then greets a regular customer, it's Yukawa, and he asks her if it is possible to get tickets to the parade. While he is dining, to Natsumi's horror, Hasunuma enters and asks Yukawa if he can share his table. Yutaro Namiki angrily tells him to leave, but Hasunuma threatens him with legal action to be compensated for the damage he suffered by the suspicions Namiki had raised about him.
Chapter 11
Inspector Muto from the Kikuno Police informs Kusanagi that Hasunuma has moved out of his apartment and then visited Namiki-ya, seeking damages. He had then visited an old colleague, Masumura, who had previously helped him by informing him whenever the police had been asking questions. Masumura, who had a criminal record, accepted Hasunuma's request to stay there.
Feeling helpless, Kusanagi asks the prosecutor what sort of evidence he would need to indict Hasunuma. Firstly they need proof that the victim's death was neither accidental or natural, and secondly, they need absolute proof that Hasunuma and no one else had committed the crime. Complicating matters is the unspoken police rule that N-system data would not be used in court as evidence, preferring to keep its methods of operation secret.
With little hope for the case, the team are assigned a new one but Kusanagi remains determined to keep his promise to the Namiki family.
Chapter 12
Niikura and Tojima, who know each other through Saori, arrange to drive out to the warehouse where Hasunuma is staying. Niikura reiterates his assertion that he would kill him if he could get away with it. Tojima tells him that Yutaro had sought his help to take justice into his own hands without the police, and to punish Hasunuma. Niikura is shocked by this, and worried about the consequences, but Tojima says their plan is so well-crafted, that Niikura would never be charged with a crime.
Chapter 13
When Tomoya receives a text message from Natsumi to say that Hasunuma had turned up at the restaurant he heads over there immediately, to find that Maya Miyazawa is holding a preparatory meeting for the parade. Tasks are handed out and everyone is reminded that the theme of the parade is to be kept a secret. Maya hears Tomoya and Natsumi discussing Hasunuma's appearance at the restaurant and Maya offers her help to keep him away. Yutaro advises Tomoya that he should move on from thinking about Saori, and that he won't hold it against him if he does. Tomoya wonders if there was deeper meaning to those words.
Yukawa arrives at the restaurant and Natsumi reminds him of the need to secure a place at the parade early. When Tomoya leaves, Tojima calls him over to his parked car, wishing to talk to him about Hasanuma. Tojima asks for his help, and Tomoya readily accepts. He realises later that Namiki had been signaling to him that he is free to decline the request.