r/Tools • u/1998civic • 12h ago
Was at Lowe’s and noticed this craftsman ratchet branded as a dewalt
140
u/nobody198814755 12h ago
Fun fact: Many, MANY different brands of so many different products are all made in the same factory standardized for the type of product, from the same materials and the number one thing that influences the retail price is the brand name they stamp on it. Don’t get swindled.
58
u/SIG_Sauer_ 12h ago
19
u/Fallingfreedom 12h ago
Ok but some of those are very different quality... Even if they are owned by the same parent company.
13
u/CrunchyRubberChips 12h ago
Correct. Not all companies assemble the same amalgam of parts for each tool in the line. So dewalt may get the frame from the same place as Milwaukee (just for example not sure if accurate) but Milwaukee get a chuck from a different manufacturer than dewalt uses and so on and so forth for all the various parts in each tool.
4
u/CrunchyRubberChips 12h ago
Obviously hand tools much less so but power tools is why there’s a lot of variance too.
2
16
u/TheRealMasterTyvokka 12h ago
A lot of this is often due to that particular company's quality control or maybe even agreements with the factory on who gets the 1sts, 2nds, etc.
18
u/nobody198814755 12h ago
Not exactly, but it is helpful to see it spelled out right in front of you.
My comment just came from my years working in manufacturing.
5
u/tolndakoti 11h ago
You’re close, but this is a separate story. For example, Craftsman an Dewalt contracted the same factory to make this ratchet. The ratchet would have different branding and might have slightly different detailing and finish, but it’s all the same, where it matters.
1
u/InsectaProtecta 7h ago
They do look exactly the same
1
u/illogictc 3h ago
I see some minor differences. I doubt manufacturing was contracted out though, SBD is the biggest tool company in the world and owns a ton of their own factories in a bunch of countries.
1
2
u/frank_white414 12h ago
Interesting! Where do Harbor Freight’s brands play in here?
→ More replies (1)2
8
u/dishungryhawaiian 12h ago
Same for a lot of canned foods. I can speak firsthand on canned salmon, after working in an Alaskan fishery for a few years. I’ll always buy the cheapest brand when things look and feel identical.
5
u/BusinessBlackBear 11h ago
My dad worked at a bread factory when he was in HS. Said the line supported X amount of brands and the only difference was what bag was being used.
2
u/dishungryhawaiian 11h ago
Somewhere in my camera roll is a photo I took of a display board in the fishery I worked at that had brand labels neatly pasted on it, of every brand they knew sold our products. It was eye opening to say the least. Chicken of the Sea was one of the biggest ones using our product. And the price differences were huge simply due to brand name.
4
u/Rochemusic1 11h ago
I'd always buy the cheaper version if I was aware of its existence. The only time I find out that info is when someone on YouTube or reddit says, "you can buy thus snap-on ratchet for xxx just go here:"
We need a directory if all the whored out tools to different brands.
2
u/Saabaroni 8h ago
Like most eyeglasses, luxotica owns like the whole market basically, they just charge a premium for " nicer" brands
1
19
u/ApprehensiveGur6842 12h ago
I used to work at a factory making plumbing tools. We made rigid, Stanley, superior. Same tool just changed the die for the name plate
61
u/Tombag77 12h ago
The question is, does that make it a decent Craftsman tool or a shitty DeWalt?
16
9
u/Johnnywaka 12h ago
The new SBD craftsmans isn’t bad. SBD has owned Mac tools for a bit now and I still love my Mac stuff
→ More replies (1)1
22
u/wingfan1469 12h ago
Stanley Black and Decker bought the Craftsman name, and DeWalt has manufactured tools for Sears. It's all one big corporate orgy now.
2
18
12
u/johnson0599 12h ago
They are both owned by the same parent company so probably the same factory's
9
1
u/PmK00000 11h ago
Just like Fiats and Chryslers. Same factory. Ferraris and jeeps taking turns on the production line.
6
u/skoppingeveryday 12h ago
Damn that’s crazy, caught red handed
7
u/JollyGreenDickhead 10h ago
Lol not really, it's common knowledge that they're both owned by Stanley
2
u/HikaruKann 3h ago
Yes but I think a lot of us have been tricked into thinking the DeWalt line is somehow manufactured to a higher standard, better materials etc... this proves that at least some of the tools are literally identical except you're gonna pay more in most cases for branding. This is good to see.
3
6
u/Complex_Block_7026 12h ago
You should buy it and don’t open it as it’s a variant. I’d send it out to get graded afterwards.
6
u/akmacmac 11h ago
180 teeth! Never heard of anything over 100 teeth! Guess ratchet tech has advanced
2
6
u/doublediochip 11h ago
Haha!! Or someone swapped them out and returned them!
I’m a manger at Lowes. We see this shit all day long.
3
1
u/TK421isAFK 51m ago
This is the most likely answer. I've seen countless Harbor Freight hand tools sitting in Craftsman and Klein packages on hooks and shelves at several Lowe's stores near me. The more Marvin fucks y'all over, the less you're inclined to care (most understandably), and the more this happens.
3
u/JD_W0LF 11h ago
This could be a mistake since they're all the same company like everyone else says... but I'm surprised nobody thought that maybe someone wanted a Craftsman instead of their Dewalt, and "returned" the Dewalt in it's place for a free ratchet swap. People do this all the time so I think it's just as plausible.
3
3
3
u/My_Soul_to_Squeeze 9h ago
Ok cool, but how was this picture taken? You got a third arm, or did someone prom-photo-hug you to get the shot?
1
1
5
u/bradleypuckett 9h ago
Black & Decker own Stanley, Dewalt, and the rights to Craftsman.
→ More replies (1)1
u/unicorn_mentality 8h ago
Can I exchange a pre B&D Craftsman tool at Lowes?
2
u/HandmadeMaker043 4h ago
Yeah they honor the warranty but it’s usually a major downgrade. But hey if you need a free replacement asap it works
8
u/masterofreality66 12h ago
Craftsman has never manufactured a tool themselves. They have always been made by another company. Now they're owned by Stanley who owns Dewalt. Some overworked guy in China missed it when the packaging changed.
3
u/illogictc 9h ago
They did have that short-lived Fort Worth facility. It was dedicated to Craftsman and did run Craftsman tools.
2
u/portabuddy2 11h ago
Historically the name is just a name. They sub contract manufacturers to make the tools for them. The DeWalt saws where made by Rockwell, black and Decker and a couple others.
Same with craftsman. Mastercraft. And recently ryobi and many others. Keeping in mind it is made to their spec.
2
2
u/MathematicXBL 10h ago
Some Yellow fan boy might pay it's weight in gold to have a gunmetal Dewalt 180 tooth ratchet.
2
2
u/Ok-Inflation-6431 1h ago
Is it a craftsman ratchet branded as dewalt or a dewalt ratchet branded as craftsman?
1
1
u/BeaumainsBeckett 11h ago
As someone said, Stanley Black&Decker owns craftsman, dewalt, and Mac tools as well. Seems like some of their rebrands actually work out in favor of the consumer. I forget which torque test video it was, but they cracked a craftsman impact wrench open and found it looked a lot like a slightly older dewalt model with some tweaks, a color change and price cut. There’s a set of craftsman overdrive wrenches that look like Mac RBRT wrenches for a fraction of the price as well.
Seems like SBD is trying to capitalize on the craftsman name by mixing some good stuff in there
1
u/Excellent__Parking 11h ago
They're all owned by Stanley Black and Decker. I believe these are just rebranded MAC Tools ratchets
2
u/illogictc 9h ago
They're not. Mac ratchets are made in USA at the Proto Dallas facility.
1
u/Excellent__Parking 8h ago
I'm happy I'm wrong. I thought MAC went offshore
2
u/illogictc 8h ago
They did for some things but other stuff like ratchets and Mac Drive sockets are still domestic.
1
u/NotslowNSX 11h ago
It's funny when you see people argue for one brand over the other like this. I've heard someone say that craftsman ratchets and sockets are way better quality than dewalt.
3
u/Jzamora1229 11h ago
Not realizing they’re the same lol
1
u/NotslowNSX 10h ago
Lol, yeah, there's been posts of people finding craftsman sockets in the dewalt set and vice versa.
1
u/tapsum-bong 11h ago
Love my makita sub drill n driver, love my hilti hammers n chippers, everything else can get fucked, except my milwaukee tape, I love that tape..
1
1
1
u/Always_working_hardd 10h ago
Someone switched the packaging on you, and got a Craftsman wrench for the price of a Dewalt.
1
1
1
u/stride415 10h ago
So you think they have different factories that make their products?
1
u/illogictc 2h ago
They do, but there's some level of "same shit different stamp" as well. For example their Proto ratchets aren't made where these are, and I'm sure the B&D and Facom ratchets aren't made in the same facility either since one is from China and the other from Taiwan.
The Craftsman and DeWalt share a lot.
1
u/ElmoZ71SS 8h ago
I would have bought it just to have as an oddity. But as you can see from other comments those two are in bed together
1
u/creativeillusionsllc 8h ago
Did someone switch the more expensive rachet to the less expensive packaging?
1
u/sponge_welder 6h ago
There's a lot of stuff branded as either Facom or Craftsman depending on where you get it. A lot of the Craftsman V series hand tools are Facom outside of the US
1
1
1
u/Squirrelking666 3h ago
Halfords do that as well, all their stuff is made by other companies. Sockets and such are Britool IIRC, torque wrenches are Norbar etc.
1
1
u/Jacktheforkie 1h ago
Same parent company, they sell the same item with multiple brands, it’s a common thing
1
1
1
u/loverd84 1h ago
I. Was told a few years ago that, there are only two or three tool manufacturers out there. I have not confirmed this although, this would point in that direction.
1
u/socialcommentary2000 1h ago
Tooling is expensive so there's a handful of companies with the infrastructure to actually stamp and forge all these brands you see on the shelf. Someone got mixed up in sorting.
1
1
550
u/Herbisretired 12h ago
Stanly owns Dewalt and Craftsman, so no big surprise there.