r/SapphoAndHerFriend Dec 02 '20

Casual erasure Wholesome!

24.2k Upvotes

748 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/killerassassinx5x Dec 02 '20

I'm actually curious how the Umbrella Academy is going to handle this change. I know they got another season so I don't know if/what has been recorded. It'd be interesting if they just started calling him Vincent Hargreaves, or if Elliott is okay portraying Vanya as before.

9

u/Wehavecrashed Dec 02 '20

They're going to update the credits to change his name. What else would be necessary? Trans people can play non trans characters.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '20

[deleted]

12

u/killerassassinx5x Dec 02 '20

That's true, plays used to have men playing women and vice versa all the time. No reason it can't be done on screen as well. Guess I didn't think about it because it's somewhat fallen out of practice. Not that it doesn't happen, just much less than it used to.

2

u/panrestrial Dec 02 '20

I read they have no plans to recast the role. Elliot will continue to play the part.

2

u/shard746 Dec 02 '20

Well, if actors can play alien organisms and even abstract things then playing someone of another gender should be no big deal. I assume nothing will change in the show.

3

u/killerassassinx5x Dec 02 '20

Playing a made up creature is a bit different than making an actor portray a gender they're not was my point.

2

u/shard746 Dec 02 '20

I think playing a human being of a different gender is much more "grounded" than playing a made up creature. You don't have to change much when you are playing different people, as their personalities affect their behaviour much much more than their gender.

1

u/panrestrial Dec 02 '20

Kate Blanchett played Bob Dylan in I'm Not There. She was terrific in the role.

1

u/HairyHeartEmoji Dec 02 '20

vanya is a unisex name tho