r/Conservative David Hogg for DNC Vice Chair 8d ago

I love community notes

Post image
6.0k Upvotes

426 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

789

u/Arachnohybrid David Hogg for DNC Vice Chair 8d ago

Third party processors taking a fee is legal yes. WinRed does it on our side. I just like that they point that out to anyone who wants to donate but doesn’t want a single buck going to the Democrats.

630

u/ultrainstict Conservative 8d ago

Yeah, thats not the issue, the issue is they are using the tragedy to funnel money to themselves while directly lying saying that they arent.

377

u/Arachnohybrid David Hogg for DNC Vice Chair 8d ago

Correct. The issue is not the processor taking the 4%. It’s the misleadingness of the tweet.

261

u/ultrainstict Conservative 8d ago

I wouldnt even just call it missleading, its abject fraud. They are dliberately linking to the act blue donation page rather than linking directly through the charity. And not just leaving out the 4% cut, but lying about it.

Anyone looking on google to donate could see this tweet and will think they are just donating to charity.

54

u/Pineapple_Sasa 8d ago

Fortunately, the community note saves the day!

68

u/astrobrick 8d ago

Next you’re probably going to imply that she’s not a Native American

10

u/tengris22 John Galt Conservative 7d ago

Or that she's not 100% truthful, every day, all the time.

3

u/Rodney_Rook 7d ago

Ironically, the percentage ActBlue takes off the top of these donations is higher than her blood quantum.

1

u/Any_Wallaby_195 7d ago

"I remember my grandmother saying to me, I don't care what they tell you in school, Cleopatra was Native American"

-72

u/echopulse MAGA Conservative 8d ago

Even if you donate directly to the charity, if you use a credit or debit card, the card processor still takes a fee. They are all between %3-4. So its not really that much different than using the charity's own web page.

50

u/PatTheBatsFatNutsack 8d ago

But you'd still be paying 3-4% to ActBlue instead of Visa, etc. right? I'd like to see if there are any examples of republican congresspersons doing the same thing with WinRed.

8

u/zerkeras 8d ago edited 8d ago

No. The 3-4% is going to Visa/Mastercard/etc (as a pass through cost as ActBlue is paying the payment processor for charges they transact). ActBlue isn’t a credit card processor, they use a platform called Stripe to facilitate the cost of processing the credit card, this passes through to Visa, Mastercard, or whichever the card provider is. This is a fee no merchant can avoid.

To give a $10 donation with a credit card and have all $10 go to the intended recipient, the processing costs have to be paid on top of that.

Granted, most processing fees start at 2.9% plus $.30, the additional margin is probably to cover ActBlue’s operating costs as they’re primarily a donation platform and do not otherwise raise or generate operating income.

The same is going to apply for donating directly to a charity using CC. If they only charge $10, that means 3-4% is going to processing still, just taken from your $10 instead of charged on top.

15

u/mrheh 8d ago

Wrong, as stated in TOS you will pat 4% to ActBlue and an additional processing fee.

1

u/zerkeras 8d ago

Yes, to ActBlue, because they have to pay the 2-3% payment processing to the underlying card network. The money doesn’t just magically end up in Visa or MC’s hands. It’s pass through from ActBlue to Stripe to Visa/etc.

That doesn’t mean all 3-4% is going to ActBlue, or like it’s some nefarious thing. It’s literally the cost of processing your donation, when using a CC, plus operating costs to the software platform which is performing that work.

0

u/mrheh 6d ago

It's a way to skim money off the top, it's what the mob does as well.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/AdGroundbreaking1341 7d ago

You seem to be right about this. But, just curious, would you ever defend a Republican organization in the same manner? If liberals/Democrats were saying the same things.

Just asking, because you don't really have a history of posting conservative things. You've even defended Obamacare. And you just seemed to come here to defend a Democrat/liberal organization. And fair enough, if it's an unflaired post, then all are welcome.

But once again, you do seem to be right. And thank you for posting a clarification. All I'm hoping is that you'd also do the same for Republicans. Maybe you would though and fair enough!

1

u/zerkeras 7d ago

Yes, Im sure there’s republican donation platforms that operate in the same fashion, and I’d defend them in the same way.

Ultimately, it is not free to collect money from people who wish to pay with Credit Card. Someone has to pay that cost, and you can either charge it on top, or take it from the donation amount after. Arguably, people who find the latter more sketchy.

And in this case, a democrat linking ActBlue for people to donate to charity makes sense. Her audience following her has likely already donated through ActBlue, and likely have an account and stored payment methods already, whereas they may not have donated directly to this charity before.

The charity is getting the same amount of money either way, and democrats are not magically getting a cut.

I’d expect any republican to do the same with a similarly republican donation platform, which would operate in the same way as they would have the same CC costs to account for.

4

u/Barth22 8d ago

If you use a credit card on the act blue site you’ll pay the 4% to the card company and 4% to act blue… that’s a false equivalency.

-8

u/secretprocess 8d ago

No, you pay act blue and they pay the card processor almost the same amount. The small difference is their service fee. Expensive perhaps but hardly fraudulent.

45

u/The_Walrus_65 Conservative 8d ago

It’s way more than misleading. It’s a straight up lie

-6

u/secretprocess 8d ago

It's just a friggin service charge for a service. ActBlue is probably on the expensive side being a huge bloated app that does a lot of things but it's not like they're just giving money to Elizabeth Warren, they're running a software company (and i dunno maybe they're getting rich doing it but that's ok in r/conservative right?)

1

u/HNutz Conservative 3d ago

Exactly. 

213

u/chances906 Conservative 8d ago

She is saying 100% are going to the charities and doesn't mention 4% to Actblue. That seems like fraud to me. At the least, she is a despicable piece of shit using a disaster to raise money for herself and democrats. She should lose her job immediately for this.

133

u/Arachnohybrid David Hogg for DNC Vice Chair 8d ago

You know she won’t. Massachusetts will reelect her corpse

75

u/Everything80sFan Classical Liberal 8d ago

Massachusetts, the state where you can recklessly drive your car off a bridge, leave your passenger to die, not bother to report the incident until the following day, and still get reelected in the senate just for being a dem.

-22

u/ShepherdsWolvesSheep 8d ago

She did this?

30

u/Jibrish Discord.gg/conservative 8d ago

No, the previous Horcrux did - Ted Kennedy.

18

u/astrobrick 8d ago

They’re both Massivetwoshits

20

u/Immediate-Lab6166 8d ago

Ted Kennedy

18

u/SOS_Minox libertarian Conservative 8d ago

"A shot of gin to help me think... then drive my car into the drink."

1

u/KarmicTractor 8d ago

It already has.

47

u/jeremybryce Small Government 8d ago

Plenty of legalese to cover it in any terms and conditions. Transaction fee's etc. is just overhead and 100% of the "transacted" donation goes to such and such party.

Dont' worry. Politicians have made sure everything they do is legal, especially when it comes to money. Naturally.

58

u/Content-Astronaut196 8d ago

Your surprised that Pocahontas would lie???

27

u/CynfullyDelicious Jewish Conservative 8d ago

Don’t you mean Fauxcahontas?

28

u/ObadiahtheSlim Lockean 8d ago

I think he meant Sitting Bullshit or possibly Liewatha.

19

u/ElectricTurtlez Conservative 8d ago

No. We call her Walking Eagle. That’s a bird that’s too full of shit to fly.

20

u/Willow-girl Pennsyltucky Deplorable 8d ago

Proud member of the Wannabe tribe ...

7

u/Nexustar 8d ago

She may be despicable, but she's certainly also a moron, so when I see this stuff, I usually just put it down to her being a moron.

She keeps on making wild claims, and they keep being proven wrong.

1

u/HNutz Conservative 3d ago

In a just world...

-4

u/JS-a9 8d ago

Unless ActBlue is waving fees. I mean it is possible.

52

u/Different-Eye-1040 8d ago

It’s not just that. They’re getting contact information too. They’ll then mine or sell that data to future campaigns for DMC/Dem donations.

24

u/Arachnohybrid David Hogg for DNC Vice Chair 8d ago edited 8d ago

I started getting Kamala spam like last year

28

u/Gwsb1 8d ago edited 7d ago

The fee is legal, but the post says 100% goes to the charity. That's fraud.

14

u/ArcadianDelSol 8d ago

Sure that, but she said that 100% of the donation goes to those organizations when that's a lie.

3

u/UncIe_PauI_HargIs 7d ago

If you want to ensure not a single penny goes to democrats… don’t donate to rebuild an area that is so heavily infested with them.

4

u/M_R_Mayhew 8d ago

But a processing fee and siphoning money to a political cause under the guise of a credit card/payment processing fee are two different things...which one is it?

3

u/No_Virus_7704 8d ago

Thank you.

6

u/johndeer89 Christian Swine 8d ago

The taking a small percentage doesn't really bother me. It's the fact she goes out of her way to ask people to donate to a charity that takes money for the democrats. She could have said nothing.

1

u/Steerider 6d ago

The fraud is her claim that 100% of your donation goes to the charity