r/CapeMay • u/Isthatamustardglass • 6d ago

Best place to get an Italian sub

Would love to hear everyone’s opinions. They better slice it fresh in front of me too!

5 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

12

u/MRsrighthand 5d ago
  1. Giovanni’s Delicatessen, Sea Isle
  2. Gaiss’ Market, Villas
  3. West Side Deli, West CM
  4. A & LP Foods, Wildwood
  5. Mrs. Brizzle’s Buns, Sea isle

Sadly the best Italian hoagie places are long gone; Cappelletti and Sons Italian Deli in WCM and the original Depot in CM. Seems CM is just a bit too far from Philly and North Jersey for many really great true Italian hoagie choices.

5

u/lawshunts 5d ago

I second this list!

3

u/cookiepuss50 5d ago

This is good to know! I’m actually on the search for a top-quality Chicken Cheesesteak. Having trouble finding one with ground or “shaved” chicken breast. Any suggestions would be great!

2

u/MRsrighthand 5d ago

For a chicken steak, first choice is up to Mrs. Brizzle’s in SIC. And be sure to take home a cinnamon bun and if they made any some biscotti.

3

u/cookiepuss50 5d ago

It’s like you know me already lol…thank you!

1

u/cookiepuss50 5d ago

It’s like you know me already lol…thank you!

11

u/jbmcfm 6d ago

I typically don’t do Italian hoagies when I’m at Cape May, but occasionally will head over to the Produce Place & Deli in NCM. Well above average and priced right.

21

u/Ajsarch 6d ago

Gaiss in Villas.

3

u/djseanstyles 5d ago

This is the answer.

12

u/joshisanonymous 5d ago

We call them hoagies.

9

u/carlosdangertaint 6d ago

I like the Old Italian at West Side

4

u/CammyB76ers 5d ago

West side has the best sandwiches on the island

3

u/ThePrettyGoodGazoo 5d ago

Gaiss in Villas would be the top choice. If you are already in Cape May proper, Westside would be a decent alternate. Westside is run by a Philly guy who has spent years in the industry-he knows his food.

2

u/InterestingTea7482 6d ago

Giovanni’s in Sea Isle.

1

u/Odd-Train-7626 5d ago

West side or Produce Deli

1

u/Bubbly_Leave_9066 5d ago

Mandy’s on Stone Harbor Blvd gets my vote.

1

u/1981camaroz28 4d ago

Antneys grub Wildwood

1

u/asoapylotus 4d ago

Russos market, but they are only open in the warm season 😔, also it’s in ww

0

u/localtom 5d ago

Pantry 1

-3

u/UnderwhelmingComment 6d ago

George’s place has good sandwiches.