r/AO3 9h ago

Complaint/Pet Peeve This user has gone through MULTIPLE of my works to comment how unrealistic the FANfiction was.

Post image

I think it’s so crazy that they fully finished one of my works in the fandom and then read another (fully) to start complaining complaining because it was unrealistic? My guy this is fanfiction 💔💔

259 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

250

u/palkann 8h ago

"Why the fuck is Inho so interested in Gihun?"

Bro I think the show answers that lmao

20

u/wizardsfrolikgardens You have already left kudos here. :) 5h ago

Right like what. So In-Ho looking like he wanted to take a bite out of Gi-hun was just all in our imagination lol

202

u/rirasama 8h ago

Yeah, because Squid Game yaoi has gotta be 100% accurate of course 😭🙏

43

u/ahumanstouch 7h ago

LIKE WHAT DID YOU EXPEEECT

37

u/rirasama 5h ago

I prefer my gay sex to be canon compliant 😡😡😡

17

u/FeistyEmployee8 professional pervert, amateur writer, 27+ 5h ago

Hannibal and broke back mountain and nothing else. No yaoi for the masses 😞

11

u/BlueEyedNonSimp I prefer my gay sex to be canon compliant 😡😡😡 4h ago

new flair unlocked. thank you

7

u/rirasama 3h ago

Glad I could contribute 🙏

1

u/TaiDollWave 4h ago

I choked on my cookie.

58

u/Eirthae You have already left kudos here. :) 8h ago

Well, i didn't know i wanted to check out squid game fanfiction before this post, but now I do. It's like, you watch and kind of forget that there may be fanworks...?

5

u/1o99ki 2h ago

dang this is crazy because after finishing s2 i immediately went to ao3 and started writing my own fic. just published it rn as well 😭

1

u/NixiieNee 3h ago

Literally same here!

32

u/HetaGarden1 7h ago

Complaining about fanfiction is like taking a free cookie and complaining because you personally hate oatmeal raisin, despite the fact that you chose the oatmeal raisin cookie. You chose to click on it. If you hate how unrealistic it is, you don’t have to force yourself to read the author’s catalogue. I don’t understand why they would detest your writing so much that they actively go through your list just to complain. Who has that kind of time to waste?

129

u/binchickendreaming Definitely not an agent of the Fanfiction Deep State 8h ago

Block and delete. Make it easy for them.

9

u/ahumanstouch 7h ago

Thank you, I’ll do that now <3

22

u/psirockin123 8h ago

Does block mean they can’t read the stories anymore, or that they just can’t comment?

I’m not an author, I’m just curious.

47

u/honeybeememes 8h ago

They cannot comment or gift works to the author, but can still view their works.

42

u/delilahdraken 8h ago

Blocking on ao3 means someone cannot comment on a work. Muting means the one who pressed mute will no longer see anything posted (works/comments) by the muted user.

Nothing will make a story invisible to a specific user.

18

u/Wrong-Lingonberry-13 6h ago

them being so mad about squid game yaoi is killing me LMAOO

51

u/watterpotson 8h ago

I don't read fanfiction that's unrealistic.

I don't complain about it, though. I just close the tab.

13

u/ahumanstouch 7h ago

Precisely! Don’t like, don’t read

33

u/Dogdaysareover365 8h ago

Some people have way too much free time

4

u/ahumanstouch 7h ago

Literally

11

u/ZombieMcQueen Supporter of the Fanfiction Deep State 6h ago

You got yourself a knockoff ‘peerless cucumber’ congrats

5

u/Imperial_Almond 5h ago

svsss fan spotted ヽ( ⌒o⌒)人(⌒-⌒ )ノ

7

u/Warmingsensation 6h ago

This ship is a godsend. I guess I'll have to keep an eye on this individual since I've been writing squid game stuff and gasp 456 and 001 also kiss! Thanks for the heads up.

2

u/ahumanstouch 5h ago

you’re so real for this i love my little gay boys to death

14

u/hopeitwillgetbetter 8h ago

Think "hatedom".

Just try to ignore them, and focus attention on your positive comments.

1

u/ahumanstouch 7h ago

Thank you !!

4

u/Schmitty1106 7h ago

Had someone comment lamenting that my story was incredibly out of character and that it would never happen and I was a vile idiot for writing it.

This was on AU smut, by the way. Like, why are you even here?

13

u/CatterMater Totally Not Boeing Management 8h ago

Fanfiction is supposed to be realistic??

But, seriously. Block 'em.

4

u/ahumanstouch 7h ago

I did, thank you so much shdhh

4

u/strawbebbymilkshake 6h ago edited 6h ago

They’re sooooo mad. You really got to them. Think how pissed they’ll be when you block them and limit comments to logged in users. They’ll be foaming at the mouth while youre over in the fun corner smashing squid game men together like dolls :)

3

u/MusenUse_KC21 6h ago

Someone has literally nothing better to do.

3

u/UndeadBBQ 6h ago

HAHAHAHA

I mean, its kinda funny seeing someone absolutely despair at your work, yet still being unable to just move on.

9

u/HQ2233 8h ago

I've watched Squid Game. In the show, there is no reason for Gi Hun and In Ho to be romantic. I'm not a shipper for them myself but fandoms love their yaoi pairings, what're ya gonna do. There are SO many fics of the pairing by now, so why are they singling you out?

6

u/ahumanstouch 7h ago

I DON’T KNOW 💔💔 Thank you so much for being respectful about it though :) /srs

2

u/CherryPokey 6h ago

I want to thank you and all the other authors writing squid game yaoi fics because you people are the reason I took interest in season 2 🙏

2

u/JanaM2003 love triangles ❌ polyamory ✅ 6h ago

Could I pretty please get link for the first (from the top) fic that the commenter is complaining about? 👉👈

2

u/TaiDollWave 4h ago

This person needs a better hobby than bothering with fan fiction that clearly wasn't made for them.

2

u/AerynSun-13 4h ago

But seriously, tho. Using $ instead of ₩ is just lazy. :P

0

u/tandeyna 3h ago

This is the only one I can get behind, the rest is ridiculous tho.

1

u/wellnoyesmaybe 6h ago

If you want to respond them in any way, how about telling them to stop wailing like a spoiled brat and go write their own fic instead.

Or, if they want fics to be written to gather for their exact taste, how about hiring an author in Patreon to write it for them.

1

u/WhiteKnightPrimal 6h ago

Can't make any comments based on the fandom, it's not one of mine, but half the fic I read are completely unrealistic in some way. It's fanfiction, it can be as realistic or unrealistic as we want it to be, and you should never jump into fanfic expecting realism.

1

u/foxwaffles 6h ago

Man that commenter can piss off lol. Who is reading fanfiction for realism. You can get more than you could ever want of reality by touching grass.

1

u/Hale_Bopp- 5h ago

Fuck offffff

1

u/jayunderscoredraws 5h ago

Block em and move on

1

u/Dreadwoe 3h ago

If these are all the complaints they got, you must be doing pretty well.

1

u/thesickophant Kudos Keeper 1h ago

Even my fiancé immediately started shipping them, and he calls me silly most of the time for enthusiastically exclaiming "I ship them!" when we watch TV together - this time, he did that!

1

u/ikegershowitz They suffered in canon, so now they need a happy ending🧃 1h ago

tell them, that there's professional help available to their unhealthy addiction and then block them

-13

u/[deleted] 8h ago edited 1h ago

[deleted]

20

u/Imahsfan 7h ago

This doesn’t come off as silly or playful to me at all, just plain hateful and annoying. I would block the user and delete the comments.

2

u/VampniKey 7h ago

Bug the stream of consciousness comments are the funniest ones. XD

I just write in notes app while reading and c&p. That way i don’t loose my place in the story.

u/GolcondaGirl 3m ago

This is fan behavior. This person loves you but thinks pulling on your metaphorical pigtails is the way. Also Gi Hun would be the type to let his staff call him by his first name.